Michael Jordan and Denny Hamlin's team and Front Row Motorsports took NASCAR to court over a system of guaranteed starting spots. The trial ended in a settlement.
23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports sued NASCAR in October 2024, alleging antitrust violations over its charter system after the Race Team Alliance failed to win permanent charters. The case reached a jury trial on 1 December 2025 and settled on 11 December 2025, with charters made permanent.
A jury trial that opened on 1 December 2025 ended in a settlement on 11 December 2025, and its central term was that NASCAR charters, the guaranteed-entry licences at the heart of the dispute, became permanent. Two Cup Series teams had accused the sport of acting as a monopoly.
The 23XI Racing lawsuit, brought with Front Row Motorsports, grew out of years of argument over the NASCAR charter system, the Race Team Alliance that negotiates it, and how money is shared between tracks, series and teams.
What is a NASCAR charter?
A NASCAR charter is an agreement, first issued in 2016, that gives a team owner a guaranteed starting spot in every Cup Series race, guaranteed purse money and other benefits. The concept is modelled on the Concorde Agreement in Formula One, and charters can be sold or leased.
The Race Team Alliance and NASCAR announced the system on 9 February 2016, a week before the Daytona 500. It created 36 charters, limited the Cup field to 40 cars and set up a team owners' council. Owners could sell a charter or lease it for a single year. Wood Brothers Racing quit the alliance three days afterwards, having been left without a charter.
The first charter deal ran through the 2020 season and was then extended to 2024 to line up with NASCAR's media rights agreement. NASCAR kept some powers over the licences. It reserved the right to take back a charter from any team that ended three straight seasons among the bottom three in owner points, although none had been taken that way as of 2023. A team may hold no more than four charters, matching the four-car limit, and in 2025 the allowance was cut to three, though Hendrick Motorsports and Joe Gibbs Racing kept four under a grandfather clause. Chartered teams may run an open fourth car, as Trackhouse Racing does with its Project91 entries.
Opinion has been split. Steve Phelps, then NASCAR president, said the sport was all-in on the system and called it valuable, while admitting that it was not profitable for chartered teams. Critics, mostly smaller single-car teams, argue that it keeps newcomers out. Ty Dillon said it made it hard for teams without top-level history or large budgets to climb up when Germain Racing sold its charter and closed in 2020, and Bob Leavine blamed the system along with the pandemic when he shut Leavine Family Racing the same year. A reporter compared the guaranteed entries to the Indy Racing League's controversial 25/8 rule at the 1996 Indianapolis 500.
The settlement gave the teams the one thing NASCAR had refused in 2024: charters that do not expire.
What is the Race Team Alliance?
The Race Team Alliance is a 501(c)(6) organisation, based in Charlotte, North Carolina, that negotiates with NASCAR for its member teams. It handles issues such as the charter system and media rights deals, and today it counts 15 Cup Series teams, led by Jonathan Marshall.
Rob Kauffman, then a stakeholder in Michael Waltrip Racing, announced it on 7 July 2014 with nine teams. By August every full-time team but Furniture Row Racing had joined. The reaction from the sport's establishment was cool: the track owner Bruton Smith and NASCAR chief executive Brian France both called the group unnecessary, while Richard Petty defended it and NASCAR president Mike Helton said it posed no threat.
The alliance has also moved into business. It helped set up an esports league in 2018, bought the short-track news site Speed51 in October 2019 and renamed it Racing America in 2021. In April 2026 Kauffman said he planned to step down as chairman, with no successor named at the time.
Why did charter talks break down?
Negotiations for the next charter agreement started in late 2022 and sped up once NASCAR secured a new media rights deal in 2023. The teams said talks were going badly. The money was at the root: under the 10-year, $8.2 billion media deal signed in 2015, 65% went to tracks, 25% to teams and 10% to NASCAR.
In October 2022 the alliance said that economic model had little chance of long-term stability, and the next month it floated holding exhibition events outside NASCAR's sanction, which raised memories of the split between CART and the Indy Racing League in the late 1990s. By April 2023 members were boycotting quarterly meetings with NASCAR, though the following month they asked for meaningful dialogue. Their central demand was that charters be permanent, which Denny Hamlin said would protect owners' investments. In February 2024 the alliance hired an antitrust lawyer, and Hendrick Motorsports vice chairman Jeff Gordon said the team had not made a profit in a decade despite being one of the most successful.
After two years of talks, NASCAR issued an offer described as take it or leave it, to be signed by 6 September 2024, two days before the first playoff race at Atlanta. Teams felt threatened and coerced, according to people who spoke anonymously to The Associated Press. A main objection was that the charters still would not be permanent, a point on which NASCAR chairman and chief executive Jim France was said to be especially firm. Every other team planning to return in 2025 signed, saying it had no choice and could not risk going out of business. Only 23XI and Front Row held out.
How did the 23XI Racing lawsuit unfold?
The lawsuit was announced on 2 October 2024. 23XI Racing, the team co-owned by Michael Jordan, and Front Row Motorsports sued NASCAR on antitrust grounds over the updated charter terms and alleged anti-competitive practices by the France family. They were represented by the sports attorney Jeffrey L. Kessler, and Judge Kenneth D. Bell heard the case in North Carolina, home to the NASCAR industry.
On 18 December 2024 the teams won a preliminary injunction that let them race as chartered entries in 2025 while the case continued. It also allowed two Stewart-Haas Racing charters, released when that team closed, to pass to the teams, one each; the third went to Trackhouse Racing. On 5 June 2025 the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned that ruling. A rehearing was denied, and from the Dover race in July the teams ran as open entries. Their six cars, driven by Noah Gragson, Bubba Wallace, Todd Gilliland, Riley Herbst, Zane Smith and Tyler Reddick, lost guaranteed starting spots if more than 40 cars tried to qualify and received much less prize money. NASCAR did change its qualifying rules so that they would make every remaining race of 2025.
In late August Reddick served the team with notice of a contract breach, and NASCAR filed notice that it would issue one charter to an entity whose name was blacked out. A hearing on 28 August on a second injunction put text messages from executives on both sides in the public record. Michael Jordan told the media afterwards that he would fight to the end for the good of the sport. The second injunction request was denied on 3 September.
Talks resumed in October, when Judge Bell ordered a settlement conference before the mediator Jeffrey Mishkin. The sides met on 21 October and again on 22 October without agreement, and on 29 October the 2025 charter agreement became public as part of the court process. When the jury was seated on 1 December, with six men and three women, the judge warned that a trial could tear NASCAR apart and urged a deal. None came, and the trial began.
What did the NASCAR antitrust trial hear?
The first witness was Hamlin, who said that team owners are essentially professional fundraisers under NASCAR's model. Hamlin said 23XI had to raise US$45 million in sponsorship simply to make a small profit, and without Jordan's ability to bring in major sponsors the team would not be profitable.
Kessler argued that NASCAR and the France family abused monopoly power, outlining evidence he said would show the sport tied up the tracks and the cars and restricted team eligibility. He likened the teams' position to a nurse with a single hospital to work for, which sets a below-market wage. He noted that Front Row owner Bob Jenkins had not made a profit in 20 years of competing, and said he would show that the France family had taken in almost US$400 million over a recent three-year period.
NASCAR's lawyer John E. Stephenson answered that the teams were suing because negotiations failed, not because of any real antitrust claim. He described a family that built the sport through hard work and risk, and said teams generated a combined US$640 million a year in sponsorship while taking in US$431 million from the new media rights deal and the charter system. If charters are so bad, he asked, why do investors keep buying them?
On the second day Hamlin was cross-examined by NASCAR attorney Lawrence Buterman. He recalled raising his concerns in 2023 with Phelps, who sent him to Jim France, and said a lunch with France during NASCAR Awards Week in Nashville left him very discouraged. According to Hamlin, France said teams spent too much and should run their cars on US$10 million a season rather than the current average of US$20 million. Hamlin said the seven-year renewable term on offer fixed a dollar amount rather than a share of the next media deal, and that 23XI's profit margin was 2.26 percent, with a best-case target of 10 percent. Buterman pointed out that the US$205 million in damages the teams sought would be a 900 percent return on Hamlin's investment; Hamlin replied that the teams wanted to be made whole.
Scott Prime, NASCAR's executive vice president for strategy, followed. Kessler used Prime's memos and presentation decks to show that NASCAR worried about a breakaway series along the lines of LIV Golf, and that its options included closer ties with the track company Speedway Motorsports. A document from Prime laid out two paths, the first being that NASCAR holds all the leverage. Prime said he opposed that route and argued for a compromise. On the third day Kessler took Prime through a 2014 report written while he worked for the consulting firm McKinsey, which proposed taxi-style medallions that became the charter system. Kessler argued that teams had nowhere else to go; Prime agreed that NASCAR is the premier stock car racing series. An email from Phelps, shown to the jury, called the teams' position playing with fire and said they could sign or lose their charters.
| Stage | Term of the charter deal |
|---|---|
| 2016 original | 36 charters; initial agreement ran through 2020, then extended to 2024 |
| 2025 offer | Renewable seven-year term, according to Hamlin; not permanent; the strike rule removed |
| December 2025 settlement | Charters permanent; strike rule reinserted and expanded to five strikes |
How did the NASCAR charter lawsuit end?
The 23XI Racing and Front Row case ended in a settlement on 11 December 2025. As part of the deal charters were made permanent, and the three-strike rule that had been dropped from the 2025 agreement came back, widened to five strikes.
NASCAR's leadership changed around the same time. Phelps became the sport's first Commissioner in 2025 and stepped away from the job in January 2026, with Steve O'Donnell assuming his duties as president. For the teams, the settlement delivered the demand that had been the sticking point since the 2024 offer: a licence that does not have to be renewed.





