Forged Versus Cast Alloy Wheels
Features

Forged Alloy Wheels Are Lighter and Stronger Than Cast, at Much Higher Cost

Photo: Ruben de Rijcke, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Source · Licence

How casting and forging shape strength, weight and price, why lighter wheels matter, and when a forged wheel earns its cost.

FeaturesBy 8 min read
The short answer

Most alloy wheels are cast by pouring molten metal into a mould, while forged wheels are pressed and hammered from solid alloy. Forged wheels are usually lighter, stronger and much more expensive, with about 20 percent higher strength-to-weight than cast or machined parts. The payoff is lower unsprung mass.

Not every alloy wheel is lighter than the steel wheel it replaces. That surprises people who assume that anything shiny must also be light, and it is the first thing to understand about the forged vs cast argument. A cast alloy wheel and a forged one can look identical on a showroom floor, yet most alloy wheels are cast and only a few are forged, and the forged ones tend to weigh less, take more punishment and cost far more.

What is an alloy wheel, and why not just use steel?

An alloy wheel is a rim made from an alloy of aluminium or magnesium. An alloy is a mixture of a metal with other elements, and it is generally stronger than the pure metal, which tends to be much softer and more ductile. Aluminium and magnesium alloys are typically lighter for the same strength, conduct heat better and often look better than steel. Steel itself is an alloy of iron and carbon, but the label alloy wheel is usually kept for wheels made of nonferrous alloys.

The traditional steel wheel is pressed from sheet metal and welded together, often leaving unsightly bumps, so it has to be painted against corrosion or hidden under a wheel cover. Alloy manufacturing allows intricate, bold designs and bare-metal finishes, though those finishes need sealing with paint or covers. Alloys also cost more to produce than standard steel, which is why they are often sold as optional extras or as part of a dearer trim package, and why they have long been standard on higher-priced luxury and sports cars.

That price tag attracts thieves, which is why makers and dealers often fit locking lug nuts or bolts that need a special key.

How cast and forged alloy wheels are madeCast alloy wheelMolten metalMouldFettlingCast wheelMost alloy wheels. Heavier and weaker, as a rule. Lower price.Forged alloy wheelAlloy billetHeating, rollingPressure,hammeringForged wheelSome alloy wheels. Usually lighter and stronger. Much higher price.
A cast wheel starts as molten metal poured into a mould, while a forged wheel starts as an alloy billet that is heated, rolled, pressed and hammered.
A cast wheel and a forged one can look identical, yet the forged one is usually lighter and stronger.

How are cast alloy wheels made?

Casting means pouring liquid metal into a mould with a hollow cavity of the desired shape and letting it solidify. It is the usual way to make complex shapes that would be hard or uneconomical to produce any other way, and it is how most alloy wheels are made. The process is some 7,000 years old, and the earliest casting that survives is a copper frog dated to 3200 BC.

A raw casting is not a finished wheel. It carries seams and imperfections from the mould, plus the access ports used to pour in the metal. Cutting, grinding, shaving or sanding these away is called fettling in British English, and it can add significantly to the cost of the product. Robots now handle some of the repetitive work, which historically was done by hand and often in conditions dangerous to health. Wheel designers shape moulds to keep fettling to a minimum.

Wheels can be cast in several ways, and magnesium wheels show the differences clearly:

  • High pressure die casting clamps a die shut in a large machine, pours molten metal into a shot sleeve and drives it into the die with a piston at high speed and pressure. The wheels are cheaper and more corrosion resistant, but less ductile and lower in strength.
  • Low pressure die casting usually uses a steel die above a sealed crucible of molten metal. Pressurised air or cover gas forces the metal up a narrow tube, like a straw, into the die. At best practice it gives better ductility than any cast aluminium wheel, though still below forged magnesium.
  • Gravity casting has been used for magnesium wheels since the early 1920s and gives good ductility. Its tooling costs are among the cheapest of any process, which allows small batches, design flexibility and short development times.

Casting is also being checked by computer. Casting process simulation predicts the quality of a cast part, with its filling, solidification, cooling, thermal stress and distortion, before production starts. It was developed at universities from the early 1970s, and commercial programs have been available since the late 1980s, saving energy, material and tooling.

How are forged alloy wheels made?

Forging shapes metal using localised compressive force, delivered by a hammer or a die. It is one of the oldest known metalworking processes, practised by smiths for millennia, and today it is a major worldwide industry. For wheels it is a complicated, multi-stage job involving heating, rolling, applying high pressure and hammering, either alone or together. The effect is to change the crystal structure of the alloy, making the material stronger and lighter. Forged magnesium wheels typically have higher toughness and ductility than aluminium ones, at much higher cost.

The temperature of the metal gives the process its name. Above the material's recrystallisation temperature it is hot forging; below that but above 30% of it, on an absolute scale, warm forging; and below 30%, usually room temperature, cold forging. Hot forging is quicker and more precise, and the recrystallisation cancels out work hardening, whereas cold forging typically work-hardens the piece.

Think of a cake baked from batter in a tin beside a loaf of bread that has been kneaded and pressed by hand. The tin gives the cake its shape, but the working changes the material of the loaf itself. That is the idea behind the advantages claimed for forging: open-die forging reduces voids, improves fatigue resistance, gives continuous grain flow and a finer grain size, and responds better to heat treatment.

For production, the maths is about volume. Closed-die forging has a high initial cost for the dies and the design work, but low recurring costs for each part, so forgings become more economical at greater volume. That is one reason closed-die forgings are common in the automotive industry. The other is strength: a forging typically offers a strength-to-weight ratio around 20 percent better than a cast or machined part made of the same material.

Two ways of delivering the force are worth telling apart. A drop hammer strikes in milliseconds and mostly works the surfaces of the piece, leaving the interior relatively untouched. A press squeezes slowly and continuously, with the dies in contact for seconds, and it deforms the whole workpiece. The press has a catch: the metal cools against the dies, becoming stronger and less ductile and perhaps cracking if the deformation continues, so heated dies are normally used. At high output it is more economical than hammering and holds closer tolerances.

Waste matters as well. In closed-die forging the surplus metal squeezed out of the die is called flash, and it can swallow 20 to 45% of the metal you started with. Flashless forging avoids that loss, but needs more complex dies, better lubrication and more careful placement of the workpiece.

Forged wheels come as one piece or as modular designs of two or three pieces, and every piece starts life as an alloy billet. A typical multi-piece wheel consists of the inner rim base, the outer rim lip and the centre piece with openings for the lug nuts, all held together with bolts. The BBS RS is among the best known of the three-piece modular forged designs.

Cast versus forged side by side

FeatureCast alloy wheelForged alloy wheel
How commonMost alloy wheelsSome alloy wheels
Starting pointMolten metal poured into a mouldAlloy billet pressed and hammered
Weight and strengthHeavier and weaker, as a ruleUsually lighter and stronger
PriceLowerMuch higher
ConstructionSingle casting, fettled afterOne piece, or two or three bolted pieces
ToolingGravity casting among the cheapestHigh initial die cost, low cost per part at volume

Which wheels are the lightest?

Magnesium came first. The earliest light-alloy wheels were magnesium, and they were the first die-cast wheels, widely called mags. They were used for racing, and their popularity in the 1960s encouraged the development of other die-cast wheels, especially in aluminium. The term mag wheel eventually came to mean die-cast wheels of any material, even the plastic and composite wheels on bicycles, wheelchairs and skateboards.

Early failures gave magnesium a bad name that it did not wholly deserve. Until the mid-to-late 1960s most aluminium wheels had low ductility, with elongation of 2 to 3%. Failures of what people called mags were later blamed on magnesium's low ductility when, in many cases, they were poorly cast aluminium alloy wheels. Once refinements in aluminium casting were widely adopted, the aluminium wheel took over as the low-cost, high-performance racing wheel.

Pure magnesium wheels are no longer made and survive only on classic cars. Vintage rims pitted, cracked and corroded readily, and a pure magnesium wheel can be ignited by a burning tyre or by prolonged scraping on the road after a puncture. Alloys of magnesium were developed to solve most of these problems. The US Federal Aviation Administration has run wide-ranging tests and concluded that the potential flammability of magnesium is no longer deemed a concern, and modern surface treatments protect against corrosion and extend the life of magnesium rims considerably.

What does a lighter wheel actually do?

Lighter wheels reduce unsprung mass, the weight the suspension has to control. With less of it, the suspension can follow the terrain more closely and so improve grip. Lower mass overall can also trim fuel consumption. Better heat conduction and a more open design carry heat away from the brakes, which helps braking under hard use and cuts the risk of fade, or even failure, from overheating. These are the real arguments for spending more on lightness.

The caveats are real, too. An alloy wheel is not always lighter than the steel one it replaces, and bigger is not better. Aftermarket alloys run from the standard 14 and 15 inches up to 30 inches. Car and Driver tried a range of alloy wheels from 16 to 19 in (41 to 48 cm), each with the same make and model of tyre, and found acceleration and fuel economy both worse as the wheels grew. Ride comfort and noise also got worse. Swapping steel wheels for lighter alloys, possibly with lower-profile tyres, can improve performance and handling, but that does not hold for ever larger wheels.

Are forged wheels worth it?

The facts support a conditional answer. A forged wheel is usually lighter and stronger than a cast wheel, and that weight saving feeds straight into the grip and braking benefits described above. Against that sits the price: forged wheels are much more expensive than cast ones. The extra money goes into the process, with its heating, rolling, pressure and hammering, and into the billet that every piece starts from.

Ownership costs apply to any alloy wheel, cast or forged. Cheaper alloys are usually not corrosion resistant, and even protected wheels will eventually start to corrode after three to five years, though refurbishment is now widely available at a cost. Alloy wheels can suffer galvanic corrosion, and without preventive measures that can make tyres leak air. They are also harder to repair than steel when bent, but their higher price usually makes repair cheaper than replacement.

For a buyer, then, the return on a forged wheel is whatever lightness delivers: less unsprung mass, more grip, better brake cooling from the open design and a small saving in fuel. Cast wheels share the alloy's looks and heat conduction at a lower price, and where the wheel is not lighter than steel the gain is smaller still.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between forged and cast wheels?
A cast wheel is made by pouring molten alloy into a mould, while a forged wheel is shaped from a solid alloy billet by heat and pressure. Most alloy wheels are cast. Forged wheels are usually lighter and stronger than cast ones, but they are much more expensive.
Are forged wheels worth the money?
They are usually lighter and stronger, and lighter wheels reduce unsprung mass, which helps the suspension follow the road and can improve grip. They are much more expensive, so the benefit is greatest where braking, handling and weight matter most.
Why are forged wheels stronger?
Forging involves heating, rolling, high pressure and hammering, which changes the crystal structure of the alloy so it becomes stronger and lighter. A forging typically offers a strength-to-weight ratio around 20 percent better than a cast or machined part made of the same material.
What is a modular or multi-piece forged wheel?
It is a forged wheel built from two or three pieces, typically the inner rim base, the outer rim lip and a centre piece with openings for the lug nuts, all held with bolts. The BBS RS is among the best known of the three-piece modular forged designs.
Are alloy wheels lighter than steel wheels?
Aluminium and magnesium alloys are typically lighter for the same strength, but not every alloy wheel is lighter than its steel equivalent. Larger alloy wheels can also hurt acceleration, fuel economy, ride comfort and noise.

Sources

  1. Alloy wheel - Wikipedia
  2. Forging - Wikipedia
  3. Casting - Wikipedia
Next story / Features

Acura CL, ILX, RLX and ZDX Ended Between 2003 and 2025 for Four Reasons