How Brake Hydraulics, the Booster and Brake Fluid Stop a Car
Features

Hydraulic Brakes Turn 10 N of Pedal Force Into 120 N at the Pad

Photo: Alf van Beem, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons · Source · Licence

A sealed loop of liquid, a lever and a vacuum diaphragm turn one foot into a hard clamp on the disc, as long as the fluid stays below its boiling point.

FeaturesBy 11 min read
The short answer

A hydraulic brake pushes fluid from a master cylinder to the calipers. Fluid cannot be compressed, so the pedal force is carried to the pads and multiplied by lever and piston areas. A vacuum booster adds force, and fluid with a high boiling point keeps vapour out of the lines.

A brake pedal that was firm a minute ago can sink to the floor for a reason that has nothing to do with worn pads: the fluid in the lines has boiled. Liquid cannot be squeezed, vapour can, and the moment bubbles of vapour appear in a brake line the pedal stops pushing the pads and starts squashing gas instead.

That one fact explains the whole design. A hydraulic brake turns a modest push of the foot into a hard clamp on the disc, a vacuum booster adds force on top, two separate circuits keep a car stoppable after a failure, and the fluid is chosen, graded and kept clean with its boiling point in mind. The chain from pedal to pad, including what DOT 3 and DOT 4 actually mean, runs as follows.

How do hydraulic brakes work?

Think of a sealed bicycle pump with a hose that runs to the far end of the garden. Push the plunger and something moves at the other end almost instantly, because the water in between has nowhere to go and cannot be compressed. A hydraulic brake is the same idea fitted to a car.

The chain starts at the pedal, which pushes a rod into the master cylinder. Inside the master cylinder one or two pistons move along a bore, and fluid from the reservoir above flows into a pressure chamber through a small compensating port. As the piston advances, pressure rises across the entire system. Fluid is driven along reinforced lines to the calipers, where it presses on pistons held by O-ring seals.

Each caliper piston presses a pad onto the spinning rotor, and the rubbing between them produces the braking torque that slows the wheel. The heat that rubbing creates escapes through the rotor's vents and channels, or flows into the pads, which are built from heat-tolerant materials, kevlar and sintered glass among them. In a drum brake the route is different at the end: the fluid enters a wheel cylinder and forces one or two shoes outward against the inside of the drum.

Letting go of the pedal reverses everything. Springs in the master cylinder push its pistons back, the pressure on the caliper falls away, and then a little suction draws the caliper piston back into its housing so the pads release the disc.

The whole arrangement is a closed system. Braking does not use up the fluid, so if the level falls there is a leak somewhere, usually a cracked O-ring or a punctured line.

PedalBoosterMaster cylinderCaliperFluidForce10 NAdds force30 N120 NTravel120 mm40 mm10 mm
A 10 N push on the pedal becomes 30 N at the master cylinder and 120 N at the pad, while 120 mm of pedal travel moves the pad only 10 mm.
Liquid cannot be squeezed and vapour can, which is the whole difference between a firm pedal and a failed one.

How does a small push become a big clamp?

Pressure is only half the story. The other half is geometry, and a simple worked example shows how much force the system can add before any power assistance arrives.

Imagine two cylinders joined by a tube and filled with fluid. The one the driver works is the master cylinder; the one beside the disc is the slave. Make the master cylinder half the diameter of the slave and its piston has a cross-section four times smaller. Push the master piston down 40 mm and the slave piston moves only 10 mm, but a force of 10 N at the master becomes 40 N at the slave. You trade distance for force, exactly as a lever does.

Now add the pedal itself, which is a lever pivoting at one end. If the pedal pad sits three times as far from the pivot as the point where it meets the master piston, the foot force is multiplied by 3 before it reaches the fluid. So 10 N from the foot becomes 30 N at the master piston, and the pad ends up pressed with 120 N. The price is travel: a 120 mm press of the pedal moves the master piston 40 mm and the pad just 10 mm.

The same trade-off explains why master cylinders come in different sizes. A larger bore delivers more fluid to the caliper pistons but needs more pedal force and less pedal stroke for a given rate of deceleration; a smaller bore does the opposite. A quick take-up master cylinder has sections of different diameters, so one set of calipers gets extra fluid volume, and it is paired with low-drag front calipers to help fuel economy.

What does the vacuum brake booster add?

Most modern four-wheel hydraulic systems add a vacuum booster, also called a servo, between the pedal and the master cylinder. It multiplies the force your foot applies, which is why a car's pedal feels light and why it turns heavy if the assistance goes missing.

The booster is a hollow housing split by a rubber diaphragm into two chambers. Both are connected to the low-pressure side of the engine, at the throttle body or intake manifold, so both hold the same partial vacuum and the diaphragm stays put. A return spring holds it in its resting position.

Press the pedal and its movement opens an air valve. Atmospheric air floods one chamber, the pressure there becomes higher than in the other, and the diaphragm is pushed towards the low-pressure side. The force it delivers equals the diaphragm area multiplied by the pressure difference, and it adds to the force of your foot on the master cylinder piston. A conservative example: with 50% manifold vacuum, a diaphragm 20 cm across has an area of 0.03 square metres and produces an assisting force of about 1500 N. A small unit does a great deal of work.

The diaphragm stops moving when the forces either side of it balance. That happens when you stop pressing and the air valve closes, or when the booster reaches what engineers call run out. At run out the pressure in the working chamber has reached atmospheric, no further force can be generated, and only your own foot can push the master cylinder piston any harder.

Why does a car have two brake circuits?

Since the 1967 US safety standard FMVSS 105, passenger-car master cylinders have been divided internally into two sections, each pressurising its own circuit. The result is called a tandem master cylinder, and most countries now make a split circuit a legal requirement. When a line or a caliper seal fails, the surviving circuit can still bring the car to rest.

There are several ways to split the work. A front/rear split gives one section of the master cylinder the front calipers and the other the rear. A diagonal split pairs the front left with the rear right on one circuit, and the front right with the rear left on the other. American Motors introduced the diagonal layout in the 1967 model year, and by the 1970s it was common on cars sold in the United States. Because the front brakes do most of the work, thanks to weight transfer under braking, a diagonal split always leaves at least one front wheel working.

Volvo chose a third route on the 140 series from the 1967 model year, so that each front wheel is served by both circuits, as is one of the rear wheels.

Two small valves look after the splitting. A proportioning valve can trim the pressure sent rearward when the driver brakes hard, which limits rear-wheel lock-up and greatly lessens the chance of a spin. A pressure differential valve, sometimes called a brake failure valve, has a piston between two chambers. While both circuits hold equal pressure the piston stays still. If one side loses pressure, the other pushes the piston across until it touches a simple electrical probe, completing a circuit and lighting a warning for the driver.

With only one circuit working, stopping distances are significantly longer, and the car should be repaired before it is driven again. Uneven wear on pads and rotors can point to low pressure or a failing circuit.

Why do hoses and lines change how the pedal feels?

The wheels move relative to the body, so near each one the rigid steel tubing gives way to flexible hose. Steel tubing that is allowed to flex fatigues and eventually fails, so the flexible section is not optional.

Standard rubber hoses expand a little more under pressure than braid does, which costs some pedal travel. A common upgrade is a set reinforced externally with braided stainless-steel wire, which gives a firmer pedal with less travel for a given effort. Anything in the system that gives or compresses is stroke your foot has to make up.

Where did hydraulic brake fluid come from?

Hydraulics arrived in stages. In 1904 Frederick George Heath of Redditch fitted a water-and-glycerine hydraulic brake to a cycle, and in March 1908 Ernest Walter Weight of Bristol fitted a four-wheel hydraulic system, using oil, to a motor car. His company advertised heavily but disappeared without the success it deserved.

Malcolm Loughead, who later respelled his surname Lockheed, patented hydraulic brakes in 1917, and in France the name is still a common word for the fluid. Fred Duesenberg fitted Lockheed brakes to his 1914 racing cars, and Duesenberg is credited with being the first to use the technology, on its Model A of 1921. The first working fluid, vegetable oil, failed the most basic requirements, so special brake fluids replaced it, each made of a base and an additive package of thickeners, anti-corrosion agents and colourants.

Today most fluids are glycol-ether based, with mineral oil used in some Citroen and Rolls-Royce systems and in bicycle brakes, and silicone in DOT 5.

DOT 3 vs DOT 4 brake fluid

The grades on a bottle come from standards. In the United States, Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 116 sets out the grades DOT 3, 4, 5 and 5.1, and many other countries use the same labels. They broadly follow the SAE specifications and the international ISO 4925 classes, with DOT 3 matching SAE J1703 and ISO class 3, and DOT 4 matching SAE J1704 and ISO class 4.

GradeBaseWater behaviourMixing
DOT 3Glycol etherHygroscopicCan be mixed with DOT 4 and 5.1
DOT 4Glycol etherHygroscopicCan be mixed with DOT 3 and 5.1
DOT 5Silicone, at least 70% by weightHydrophobicNot with any other grade
DOT 5.1Non-silicone, less than 70% siliconeHygroscopicCan be mixed with DOT 3 and 4

Compliant fluids must be colourless or amber, except DOT 5 silicone, which has to be purple. Fluid that has been in a car for a while can be any colour.

The grades are ranked by performance, and the direction of any swap matters. A car that specifies DOT 3 can take DOT 4 or DOT 5.1, a temperature upgrade, provided the rubber parts accept the borate compounds that lift the boiling point. A car that needs DOT 4 might see its fluid boil if DOT 3 goes in. DOT 3, 4 and 5.1 are all glycol based and can be mixed, though replacing the old fluid completely gives the specified performance. DOT 2 should never be mixed with anything.

DOT 5 stands apart. It is silicone, immiscible with water and with the other fluids, so a system can change over only after a complete restoration. It keeps a stable viscosity across a wide temperature range and does not damage paint, but it is not compatible with anti-lock brakes, because it can aerate when the ABS operates. It also absorbs a small amount of air, so bleeding needs care. DOT 5.1 came about because silicone found little acceptance: it offers silicone-like performance with the familiarity of the glycol fluids.

Viscosity matters because anti-lock braking, traction control and stability control use micro-valves that must react fast. Low-viscosity versions of DOT 4 and DOT 5.1, sold as DOT 4+, Super DOT 4 or DOT 5.1 ESP, meet the ISO 4925 class 6 limit of 750 mm2/s at -40 degrees C (-40 degrees F).

Why does brake fluid absorb water?

The glycol-ether fluids, DOT 3, 4 and 5.1, are hygroscopic. That is a technical way of saying they draw moisture out of the air at ordinary humidity. It sounds like a flaw and, for the boiling point, it is one, yet the property was chosen on purpose.

Standards quote two boiling points for each fluid. The dry figure applies to fresh fluid. The wet figure applies after the fluid has absorbed a few percent moisture, and it is usually much lower, though it remains above most normal service temperatures. Brake fluid gets extremely hot, particularly in drum wheel cylinders and disc calipers, so a high boiling point is the safeguard against the vapour problem described at the start. Once vapour is in the line, the hydraulic transfer is lost and the brakes fail to stop the car.

Glycol fluid also spreads the moisture evenly through the system and carries corrosion inhibitors that protect calipers, wheel cylinders, the master cylinder and ABS valves. Silicone and mineral-oil fluids are hydrophobic and keep their boiling point over their service life, but silicone does not disperse any water already in a system, and it can suffer water pooling and freezing or boiling over time. That risk is the main reason single-phase glycol fluid is the usual choice.

Silicone does make sense in one setting. A system filled from dry with silicone, on a car with no ABS and no history of glycol fluid, needs no scheduled fluid changes, only a refill when a component has been repaired or renewed. Since the 1990s the US armed forces have standardised on silicone, and cold countries such as Russia and Finland use it widely. Citroen LHM mineral oil has no corrosion at all, but it cannot replace other fluids without new seals, because the rubber is incompatible.

What causes a spongy brake pedal?

A spongy pedal means your foot is travelling further for the same braking force, and a few causes stand out. Compressibility is the central one. As a fluid becomes more compressible, more pedal travel is needed for the same caliper piston force, so brake fluids are required to stay incompressible across a range of temperatures.

Boiled fluid is the extreme case, because vapour is far more compressible than liquid. Silicone shows a milder version: it is more compressible than glycol, and the result is brakes with a spongy feeling. Hoses that expand under pressure cost travel too, which is why braided lines feel firmer. Air is another form of the same problem, and DOT 5 takes in a small amount of it.

Contamination is the quieter cause. Water, alcohol, antifreeze or the wrong fluid can crack the O-rings, and a cracked seal means a leak. Low or contaminated fluid can reduce braking performance and, in extreme cases, lead to brake failure.

What does this mean for your car?

Brake fluid is toxic and harms paintwork, so spills deserve prompt attention. Use the grade your car specifies. Going up from DOT 3 to DOT 4 or DOT 5.1 can be fine if the seals tolerate it, and going down from DOT 4 to DOT 3 can cost you boiling margin. Never put silicone into a system that has had glycol fluid, or glycol into a silicone system, because the mix can corrode components around trapped moisture.

Pressure varies with the machine: a Formula 1 car subjects its fluid to more than 75 bar (1,100 psi), where motorcycle brakes peak at 8 to 15 bar (120 to 220 psi). The physics is the same at both ends.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a hydraulic brake multiply pedal force?
Two stages of leverage do the work. The pedal acts as a lever, and the fluid then pushes on a larger piston at the wheel. With a lever ratio of 3 and a slave piston of four times the area, 10 N of foot force ends up as 120 N at the pad, in exchange for much less movement.
Why does a brake pedal go hard when the engine is off?
The booster takes its vacuum from the engine. Vacuum on one face of the diaphragm and outside air on the other create a pressure difference, and the resulting force joins the driver's own. Once assistance runs out, the foot alone has to push the master cylinder piston.
Is brake fluid hygroscopic, and does that matter?
DOT 3, 4 and 5.1 are glycol-ether fluids, and glycol takes moisture from ordinary air. The benefit is that water is spread through the system alongside corrosion inhibitors. The drawback is a lower wet boiling point once the fluid has taken some up, which is why standards quote dry and wet figures.
Can I mix DOT 3 and DOT 4 brake fluid?
Both are glycol based, as is DOT 5.1, so they can be combined, although a full change is better for specified performance. Silicone DOT 5 should stay away from every other grade, and DOT 2 should not be mixed with anything.
Why does my brake pedal feel soft?
Compressibility is the common thread. Whatever lets the system give, whether vapour from boiling fluid, silicone fluid, air or a hose that expands under pressure, costs extra pedal travel for the same clamping force. Contamination that cracks a seal can add a leak on top.

Sources

  1. Brake fluid - Wikipedia
  2. Master cylinder - Wikipedia
  3. Hydraulic brake - Wikipedia
Next story / Marques

Citroen: The Engineering Story Behind the Traction Avant, 2CV and DS