Three American insurers, three different answers to who gets cover and how it is sold, from a hotel meeting of 25 Army officers to a specialist for classic cars.
USAA insures US military members, veterans and their families and sells directly. Erie Insurance sells through independent agents in 12 states and Washington DC. Hagerty is the world's largest specialist insurer of classic vehicles. Each one narrows who it serves, and that is how they differ from mainstream car insurers.
A car insurer exists because 25 US Army officers could not find anyone willing to cover their cars while they moved from posting to posting. They met at the Gunter Hotel in San Antonio on 20 June 1922 and agreed to insure one another. That company, USAA, now sits 93rd on the Fortune 500, and it is one of three very different answers to the question of who gets to buy car insurance.
Who can get USAA car insurance?
USAA sells almost entirely to members of the US military, veterans and their families. That covers officers and enlisted personnel on active duty, in the National Guard and in the Reserve, plus officer candidates in commissioning programmes and anyone who served and left honourably. Since 2022, a general discharge has counted too.
The door opened slowly. For years only US military officers, along with certain other federally sworn officers, could join, and their descendants could buy insurance from a sister company called USAA-CIC. An officer could sign up whether active or retired. The National Guard and Reserve were admitted in 1973, and enlisted members of the armed services followed in 1996.
Enlisted veterans are a very large group, so USAA first limited eligibility to people who were serving or had recently separated, and applied that same time limit to officers. In 2008 it widened membership to all military personnel and retirees, and to every veteran who separated after 1996. By November 2009 any honourable veteran, whenever they served, could take out cover.
A handful of federal agencies sit alongside the armed forces. Current and former staff of the FBI, the Drug Enforcement Administration, the Secret Service, the Naval Criminal Investigative Service, the Defense Criminal Investigation Services, the Air Force Office of Special Investigations and the Army Criminal Investigation Command all qualify. From the State Department, only Foreign Service Officers, plus some Foreign Service Employees on permanent appointments, qualify. Staff and faculty of the Merchant Marine Academy qualify only if they hold a commission granted by the Marine Administration. For a short time, federal law enforcement could enrol as well.
Civilians had one narrow window. Between September 2009 and August 2013, USAA offered restricted membership that reached investments, life insurance and most bank deposit accounts. Car and home policies stayed closed to non-military members because of eligibility restrictions, so even in that period a civilian could not buy USAA car insurance.
Erie sells only through independent agencies, more than 2,200 of them, which employ over 13,000 licensed agents.
Why did Army officers start their own insurer?
Insurers of the day struggled with customers whose address kept changing. Officers who moved so often could not secure car cover, so on 20 June 1922, 25 of them met in San Antonio to set up a mechanism for mutual self-insurance. The group was first called the United States Army Automobile Association.
The name changed in 1924, when commissioned officers of other US military services became eligible, and it has been the United Services Automobile Association ever since.
Early success did not guarantee survival. By the late 1920s, rival factions were fighting for control of the organisation and its long-term viability was in doubt. The feuding members settled it by agreeing to hire an outsider, and in 1928 Major General Ernest Hinds took the posts of general manager and secretary-treasurer. He brought stability and stayed until he died in 1941.
Mail carried most of the business until the 1960s. Robert F. McDermott, a retired Air Force brigadier general, became chief executive in 1969. The San Antonio office building went up on his watch, and he pushed the company away from the post and towards the telephone. A toll-free number arrived in 1978. Robert T. Herres, also a retired Air Force general, took over in 1993, extended services to enlisted members and developed financial services over the Internet. USAA began Internet sales and service through its website in June 1999.
Later chapters were less tidy. Robert G. Davis became chief executive in 2000 and presided over membership, assets and net worth that grew significantly. He also oversaw the company's first layoffs, and he retired abruptly in December 2007. Wayne Peacock, the first chief executive who was not a veteran of the armed forces, took over in February 2020 from Stuart Parker, and Juan C. Andrade has been in the job since April 2025.
How does USAA sell and service its policies?
USAA was a pioneer of direct marketing. The bulk of its trade goes through the Internet or the telephone, and members deal with its own employees rather than with agents. That habit has deep roots: the organisation started by mail, moved to telephones from the late 1960s and added a website in 1999.
The headquarters sits in northwest San Antonio. Phoenix is the second major office, and the bank, USAA Federal Savings Bank, is one of the largest in the United States, based on a 575-acre (233 ha) campus there. Further offices operate in Chesapeake in Virginia, Colorado Springs, Plano in Texas and Tampa, with overseas sites in Dublin, London and Frankfurt.
The Phoenix presence keeps growing. A 400-acre multi-use campus in north Phoenix, built in 2017, holds 4,500 workers. In May 2019 USAA opened another north Phoenix office for 1,100 employees, mostly software developers. In May 2021 it announced 750 extra jobs in Charlotte, North Carolina, to add to a base of 100, in 90,000 square feet of space. In June 2022 it paid $97 million to developer Beacon Partners for the building, called The Square.
Technology has long been a strength. From 2009 USAA was among the earliest banks to accept cheque deposits made by mobile phone, and it went to court repeatedly to defend its patent claims over the technology. In May 2020 Charles Schwab Corporation bought its investment management and brokerage accounts for $1.8 billion.
The brand reaches well beyond policy sales. USAA has sponsored the National Football League since 2011 and the Wounded Warrior Project since 2009. It is a partner of the Army Black Knights, the Navy Midshipmen and the Air Force Falcons, the three service academies in NCAA Division I, and it has presented the Army-Navy Game since 2009 under a multi-year deal that runs through 2030.
Where has USAA run into trouble with regulators?
The penalties on record fall on its banking arm rather than on car insurance. In 2019 the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) uncovered 600 breaches of two laws, the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act and the Military Lending Act. In March 2022 the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network imposed a $140 million civil money penalty on USAA Federal Savings Bank for breaking the Bank Secrecy Act.
In August 2024 USAA paid $64.2 million to settle claims that it had broken the first of those laws, having charged illegal fees and excessive interest on loans. December 2024 brought a cease and desist order from the OCC, which told the bank to fix weaknesses spanning management, earnings, information technology, consumer compliance, internal audit and suspicious activity reporting.
What is Erie Insurance and where can you buy it?
Erie Insurance Group is a Pennsylvania company, headquartered in the city of Erie, that writes car, house, business and life policies, all sold by independent agents. It has more than 6 million policies in force, a rating of A+ (Superior) from A.M. Best, and operations in 12 states and the District of Columbia.
Pennsylvania is home turf, and the others are Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Tennessee and Wisconsin, plus Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia. The group ranked 347th on the 2021 Fortune 500 list, based on revenue for the 2020 fiscal year, and a later ranking puts it at 368th. It first appeared on the list in 2003.
Several subsidiaries sit under the Erie name: Flagship City Insurance Company, Erie Family Life Insurance Company, Erie Insurance Company, Erie Insurance Property & Casualty Company and Erie Insurance Company of New York. The life company holds an A (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best, a notch below the parent group.
How did Erie begin?
Erie began as a walkout. H.O. Hirt and O.G. Crawford sold policies for the Pennsylvania Indemnity Exchange until 1925, when they quit to start a rival. In three months and 20 days they persuaded 90 stockholders to back a hand-written business plan and raised $31,000. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department then licensed the new Erie Insurance Exchange to write car insurance, and it began operating on 20 April 1925.
Structure mattered. The Exchange was formed as a reciprocal, with Erie Indemnity Company as its managing company, and the annual premium charge per auto was $34.
Hirt wanted a company built on service and gave it a mantra that hid its own name inside the word: "The ERIE is above all in sERvIcE." Customers were encouraged to call collect, and might find the cofounders answering the telephone themselves. Sam P. Black Jr., who was the first adjuster and also ran claims full time, had a telephone line put into his lodging at the local YMCA so that policyholders could ring him at any hour.
In 1934 Erie created the "Super Standard Auto Policy," which other insurers used as a model across the country. It carried extras that were rare in the 1930s, among them "Drive Other Car" protection and no collision deductible when two cars both insured by Erie hit each other. Home, business and life cover came later.
Until 1928 Erie operated from a single office in its home city. Pittsburgh came next, and in 1953 a branch campus opened in Silver Spring, Maryland.
Why does Erie insist on independent agents?
Erie sells only through independent agencies, more than 2,200 of them, which employ over 13,000 licensed agents. Chief executive Terry Cavanaugh told the Erie Times-News in February 2013 that the company stood by that channel, while accepting that customers also need to pay bills and file claims online.
That is the reverse of USAA, which deals with members directly through its own staff. A buyer of Erie car insurance meets an agent in business for themselves, and a USAA member meets an employee.
The recognition Erie has collected centres on service. Its claims service took the Achievement in Customer Excellence (ACE) Award for Voice of the Customer in 2017, the second year running. It has made the Ward's 50 list of top-performing property-casualty insurers every year since 1991, a ranking that weighs financial safety, consistency and five-year performance across a field of nearly 3,000 property-casualty carriers and 1,407 life-health carriers. In 2018 it became Erie County's largest employer, with more than 2,800 people working locally.
Erie also scored 100 percent on the 2017 Corporate Equality Index, and in February 2020 Forbes named it among the best employers for diversity. Hispanic Network Magazine and Black EOE Journal have each named it their top insurance company since 2013.
Outside insurance, the group paid in May 2012 for the right to name Tullio Arena in the city's downtown, and the venue became Erie Insurance Arena. In 2018 it became title sponsor of the Roar on the Shore motorcycle rally, which no longer runs. Its logo pairs the company name with the cupola of the H.O. Hirt Building, a design introduced in the 1990s and updated in 2005.
What does Hagerty classic car insurance cover?
Hagerty is the biggest specialist insurer of classic vehicles anywhere. From its base in Traverse City, Michigan, it also runs operations in Canada, Germany and the United Kingdom. Beyond insurance, it calls itself an automotive lifestyle and membership business.
It began with boats. Frank and Louise Hagerty launched the company in 1984 because they could not find good insurance for their wooden boats. Antique boats came first, then cars and other vehicles, and in 1991 the company added cover for classic cars.
In 2000 their son McKeel Hagerty became chief executive and built a media arm, launching a magazine for the classic and enthusiast market that was renamed Hagerty Drivers Club Magazine in 2020. The first annual Hagerty Price Guide, a valuation tool for classic car buyers, followed in 2008. The company also originated both the Historic Vehicle Association and the RPM Foundation.
How did Hagerty grow into more than an insurer?
In 2017 Hagerty adopted a mission to keep driving alive and protect car culture for later generations. To back that up, the company launched Hagerty Drivers Club, which gives members access to events, automotive discounts and roadside service. It also became owner and organiser of the Greenwich Concours d'Elegance, set up MotorsportReg.com and Hagerty Garage + Social in 2019, and in 2021 it bought the Amelia Island Concours d'Elegance, the Concours d'Elegance of America and the California Mille.
In December 2021 the company went public by merging with a special purpose acquisition company, Aldel Financial, under the symbol HGTY, in a deal valued at $3.13 billion. Bloomberg News reported in 2023 that, in just two years, McKeel Hagerty had grown a small family firm into a conglomerate that leads the classic car insurance market.
Not every venture landed cleanly. In January 2023 Hagerty launched an offset scheme for classic motorists to cancel out their carbon emissions, with a partner planting trees on their behalf. Scrutiny followed when the partner was reported to be keeping 20-30% of donations before passing funds to other charities, and no calculations were provided for the CO2 or tree figures.
Gaming offered a lighter outing for the brand. In 2022 Hagerty partnered with Polyphony Digital to appear in Gran Turismo 7, with its branding on the Legend Cars Dealer screen and McKeel Hagerty describing the cars in the "Hagerty Collection."
Hagerty vs Erie vs USAA: how do they compare?
| Insurer | Started | Headquarters | What sets it apart |
|---|---|---|---|
| USAA | 1922 | San Antonio, Texas | Military members, veterans and their families only; sold direct by Internet or telephone |
| Erie Insurance | 1925 | Erie, Pennsylvania | Independent agents only, in 12 states and the District of Columbia |
| Hagerty | 1984 | Traverse City, Michigan | Specialist cover for classic vehicles, also operating in Canada, Germany and the United Kingdom |
What does this mean for someone buying car insurance?
The three names answer three separate questions. If you or a relative served, USAA car insurance is open to you, and you will deal with the company directly. If you live in one of Erie's 12 states or in Washington DC and want a local agent, Erie is built for that, with a policy history that includes an early "Drive Other Car" feature. If the car in the garage is a classic, Hagerty exists for exactly that kind of vehicle.
Hagerty vs Erie is therefore less a contest than a sorting exercise, since one is a national specialist for older vehicles and the other a regional generalist working through agents. Neither one is open to everyone in the way that a mass-market insurer is, and USAA is the most selective of the three.
What is still open for USAA and Hagerty
A few dates already look ahead. USAA's Army-Navy Game sponsorship runs through 2030. Andrade took over as chief executive in April 2025, and the December 2024 order from the OCC leaves the bank with a list of faults to put right. Hagerty, now listed under HGTY, continues to run events, a magazine and a membership club alongside its policies.




