How the first UK car insurance comparison site slipped to fourth place, why its Cardiff neighbour picked policy features over price, and how a nodding dog sold cover without a middleman.
Confused.com and Go.Compare are UK comparison sites, both based in Cardiff, that line up car insurance and other products. Confused.com launched in 2001 as the first of its kind. Go.Compare began in 2006 and focused on policy features. Churchill is an insurer that sells direct and is part of Direct Line Group.
In 2001 a Cardiff-based website became the UK's first car insurance comparison site, and it called itself Confused.com. Two decades later it ranks only fourth in its field and was sold by Admiral Group to RVU. Its rivals took other roads: Go.Compare built its pitch on what policies actually contain, while Churchill sold its own policies directly.
What is Confused.com and how does it work?
Confused.com is a UK comparison platform, with a website and an app, that puts insurance and financial products side by side. Car insurance is the headline, but the range also covers home cover, energy, van insurance and life insurance. It launched in 2001, has offices in Cardiff, Wales, and is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
It was part of Admiral Group plc until 30 May 2021, when Admiral sold it to RVU. Being first mattered: it was the UK's first car insurance comparison site. Being first has not kept it at the top, because it has since slipped from market leader to the fourth largest of its kind in the country.
Go Compare was the first comparison site to focus on features of insurance products rather than just listing prices.
Who has run Confused.com?
Few comparison sites have changed leaders as often. Kate Armstrong, who founded the business and was its first managing director, came from IT consulting and was originally from Sydney. She retired in 2005 after Admiral Group floated successfully. Deborah Williams took over for two years, a period of rapid growth in which profit reached 36 million pounds in 2007. The industry was surprised when she left to join a relatively unknown insurance broker.
Carlton Hood followed as the first person to hold the new title of chief executive. The market then took a jolt: the Compare the Market campaign of 2009 broke new ground, and Confused.com and its established rivals all lost share. Hood resigned abruptly in 2010. Group finance director Kevin Chidwick filled in until January 2012, when an Admiral senior manager, Nic Weng Kan, took over, and Martin Coriat arrived in October 2013 after running Admiral's French comparison site, LeLynx.fr.
Marketing saw similar turnover. Joby Russell became marketing director in August 2012, oversaw the launch of the Brian the Robot campaign and the later toy promotions, and left in May 2015 to join the online estate agent Purplebricks.com. Paul Troy, who had spent 2011 to 2013 at Moneysupermarket, became chief marketing officer in late 2015, and Sam Day replaced him in May 2018.
Louise O'Shea, the finance director, was promoted to chief executive in September 2017 when Coriat moved across to LeLynx. She stepped down in March 2023 after almost six years. Her successor, Steve Dukes, had joined in 2019 as the company's first chief operating officer, after product and general management roles at fast-growing financial services and eCommerce firms and a spell as chief executive of Commuter Club.
How did Confused.com's advertising change?
The early adverts were plain: a man explained what the site offered, in a direct response format that used a slightly different variant from 2003 to 2005. The longest-running campaign followed, from 2005 to 2008, with cardboard props on a white background and people announcing that they were Confused.com. A 2002 study by Webster ranked the slogan third among that year's most used phrases, behind "Hey you" and "Naughty Soldier."
Nothing that came later matched it. As rivals Compare the Market, Moneysupermarket.com and Go.Compare piled in, Confused.com tried one vehicle after another, and none repeated the first success.
From around 2009 the adverts used real testimonials, with customers and heavy social media users such as Phil Lester explaining how the website worked. Early 2010 brought a campaign about regret, in which members of the public wished they had bought their car insurance through the site. In September 2010 came Cara Confused, an animated, wild-haired take on the old company mascot, inspired by the founder Kate Armstrong. In February 2011 Cara, voiced by West End performer Louise Dearman, sang Diana Ross's "Chain Reaction," and Marketing Director Mike Hoban claimed the campaign had brought in 2 million customers.
Then came a robot. On 1 June 2013 an advert introduced Brian, a robot on a mission to help people "save pounds." On 24 December 2014 scrap dealers kidnapped him and left him hanging on a magnet, and a couple of weeks later his five robot colleagues, the Herberts, raced to stop the incinerator. Brian was repaired in March 2015. A toy version arrived in August 2015, with Miss Herbert and Stunt Herbert toys following in early 2016.
The robots were scrapped on 1 August 2016 in favour of James Corden. After five adverts, Timothy Murphy replaced Corden on 17 August 2018, driving through a mass of confusing messaging towards a clear road to the sound of Link Wray's "Rumble."
Sponsorship filled the gaps. Confused.com has backed ITV programmes including Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? and the drama Quiz, Emmerdale, Catchphrase, Celebrity Squares, Sunday Night at the Palladium and Ninja Warrior UK, along with The Simpsons on Sky. It once sponsored the ITV National Weather, and in 2019 it joined Land Rover in sponsoring ITV's Rugby World Cup coverage.
What is Go.Compare and how is it different?
Go.Compare is the trading name of GoCompare.com Limited, a Cardiff-based comparison company. Its site compares car insurance, pet and home policies and breakdown cover, and Future plc has owned it since 2021. The Financial Conduct Authority authorises and regulates it, and no other comparison website has been invited to join BIBA, the British Insurance Brokers Association.
That invitation traces back to how the site began. Go Compare was established in November 2006 by Hayley Parsons, who had spent 14 years at Admiral Insurance and had earlier led business development at Confused.com. Her new site was the first of its kind to concentrate on the features of insurance products rather than simply listing prices, and that approach led BIBA to invite it in.
Its range stretches well beyond motor. Vehicle and home cover sit beside life insurance, offered with partner Neilson Financial Services, pet insurance and breakdown cover. Preferred providers including Experian and Energylinx help it compare travel cover, energy, broadband, loans, credit cards and mortgages. In August 2012 it launched an online magazine, Covered, that claimed to be unlike any other financial publication.
Confused.com vs Go.Compare vs Churchill: how do they compare?
| Company | Started | Based | Owner | How it works |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Confused.com | 2001 | Cardiff, Wales | RVU since 30 May 2021, previously Admiral Group | Comparison site and app; first UK car insurance comparison site |
| Go.Compare | November 2006 | Cardiff, Wales | Future plc since 2021 | Comparison site that put policy features ahead of price lists |
| Churchill | 1989 | Bromley, London | Direct Line Group since February 2012 | Sells to customers direct; policies underwritten by U K Insurance Limited |
Who has owned Go.Compare?
The ownership trail is crowded. By 2011 the insurer esure held 49 per cent, and on 8 December 2014 it bought the whole company in a deal worth 95 million pounds. Parsons was replaced as chief executive by Jon Morrell in March 2015. The company was demerged from esure in November 2016, and in November 2017 an offer from ZPG to buy it for 460 million pounds was rejected.
The following month it bought MyVoucherCodes, a big UK online voucher code site, for 36.5m pounds. In November 2020 it agreed a takeover offer of 594m pounds from Future plc, Britain's biggest magazine publisher. Lee Griffin, one of the original founders, has led the company since 2021, and in September 2024 it relocated to Hodge House, also in Cardiff.
The numbers since the takeover are public. In July 2025 Go.Compare was reported as the second most profitable company in Cardiff, with a pre-tax profit of 72.3 million pounds in the year to September 2024, against 46.2 million pounds a year earlier. Future reports it as a separate operating segment. For the financial year to 30 September 2025 the segment's revenue was 191.8 million pounds, down from 202.7 million, roughly 26 per cent of what Future earns as a group.
Who is Gio Compario, the Go.Compare tenor?
On 19 August 2009 Go.Compare launched a campaign around Gio Compario, a fictional Italian tenor played by Wynne Evans, who sings about the company in assorted places to the tune of "Over There." By 2015 the public had voted it the UK's most irritating advertisement.
The company answered by poking fun at itself. In July 2012 a run of adverts had celebrities including Stephen Hawking, Sue Barker, Jimmy Carr, Ray Mears, Stuart Pearce and Louie Spence line up to silence him. Marketing officer Kevin Hughes called it a risk but said brands must listen to customers. Gio came back in July 2015 after an 18-month break, in what Evans called a much calmer performance, and again in July 2020 once lockdown measures eased.
In 2023 the brand was refreshed to stress its ".compare" domain, and the launch was built on a link with ITV's The Voice, which earned bronze for media sponsorship at the 2023 Campaign Media Week Awards. Since 2024 the aim has been to modernise, playing Gio down and concentrating on how the site makes people feel.
What trouble has Go.Compare faced?
The record includes a few uncomfortable moments. In September 2007 the company admitted that customer data had once been passed on unlawfully, blaming a sub-contractor, Performance Direct, that had broken its contract, and promising immediate steps to prevent a repeat.
Search was a bigger blow. In January 2008 Google banned the site for a time over "irregular inbound links," and the portion of searches for "car insurance" that it captured fell from 17.49% to 2.31%. It was banned again in April 2009.
Fraud became a focus afterwards. In 2015 Go.Compare launched a technology-led fraud prevention service, expanded with more layers in 2018, and in 2019 it joined the Insurance Fraud Bureau, the only price comparison website to do so. That August it drew criticism from road safety organisations for an advert showing Gio crashing into a tree and flipping over, and the Advertising Standards Authority received over 70 complaints.
Go.Compare and the Welsh Rugby Union
In July 2023 it agreed a four-year deal as back of shirt sponsor of the Welsh Rugby Union, which also supports grassroots rugby across Wales.
What did Go.Compare do in 2025?
In March 2025 it acquired the RNWL app, later rebranded Renewal, a secure place to store insurance policies and important documents. Renewal works with Go.Compare to give consumers a broader tool for managing their finances.
How does Churchill car insurance work?
Churchill is a British insurer based in Bromley, London. It started in 1989 among the earliest UK companies to sell car insurance straight to the customer, with no comparison page in the middle of the sale. Since February 2012 it has been part of Direct Line Group, and its policies are underwritten by the parent company, U K Insurance Limited.
Martin Long launched it as a direct car insurance provider, with backing from Winterthur, at the time a subsidiary of Credit Suisse. Home insurance joined the range a year later. In 1995 it opened its first website and launched a credit card, and it became the first insurer in the United Kingdom to offer motor insurance estimates on interactive media kiosks.
The late 1990s brought certification and a new address. In 1996 Churchill won Investors in People and ISO9002 accreditation, and added breakdown cover. In 1997 it made the Britain's Best Employers list for the first time, moved into its current headquarters at Churchill Court and introduced travel and pet insurance. In October 1999 it bought the motorcycle insurance broker Devitt Insurance and launched its first e-commerce facility, which let customers get car and home quotes online.
The 2000s were about acquisitions. In 2000 it obtained the Churchill.com domain name, and in February that year acquired NIG. It bought Prudential's insurance business in February 2002, and in June 2003 the Royal Bank of Scotland Group purchased the whole business for 1.1 billion pounds, placing it alongside Direct Line, another company Long had helped launch.
After the 2008 bailout of RBS by the UK government, Brussels required the group to sell some assets, the insurance division among them. In February 2012 the new Direct Line Group absorbed Churchill, ahead of a divestment completed in February 2014.
What does Churchill sell and what has it won?
Churchill offers car, home, pet and travel insurance, plus breakdown cover arranged with Green Flag. Life insurance comes through Legal & General, and motorbike insurance is arranged through Devitt Insurance Brokers. Its one commercial product is van insurance, administered by Brightside Insurance Services.
The trophy cabinet is full of Your Money Awards. Churchill won Best Motor Insurance Provider in 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2006 (jointly with Direct Line) and 2008, and Best Online Motor Insurance Provider in 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2006 and 2007. Other wins covered home and contents, travel and pet cover, with the last of those coming in 2010.
Why is Churchill a nodding dog?
In 1994 the company wanted a mascot that would set it apart from the former prime minister Winston Churchill. A staff competition produced a bulldog, a familiar symbol of British identity, and a real bulldog named Lucas was the first Churchill dog. The nodding dog appeared in 1996, named after the wartime leader.
In the television adverts the animated dog is asked if he can cut insurance bills, and he answers with the catchphrase "Oh, yes!", believed to imitate the caretaker Potter from the 1970s television series Please Sir!. Bob Mortimer voiced the dog from 1996 to 2011, first answering questions from his comedy partner Vic Reeves, and Stephen Alan Yorke took over from December 2011 to September 2019.
Props grew bigger. In 2004 a Churchill hot air balloon, 34 metres wide and 24 metres high, was unveiled and has since turned up at events from the London Marathon to the Bristol International Balloon Fiesta. In 2006 the "Challenge Churchill" campaign invited the British public to dare the dog to find cheaper car and home insurance, and in 2009 the strapline became "Count on Churchill." The dog appeared in twenty-two pantomimes that year and visited Pontins holiday camps in 2010.
Martin Clunes played the dog's new owner from December 2011 to November 2012, and Dawn French took over from February 2013 until June 2014. From June 2015 to January 2018 the dog went solo again, among talking furniture, cars and homes, under the slogan "Depend on the Dog." In October 2019 the nodding dog design was dropped for a realistic, non-speaking CGI version in the "Chill" campaign.
The company has also used sport. In October 1993 it began a three-year sponsorship of the World Indoor Bowls Championship, and in August 2000 it became shirt sponsor of Crystal Palace FC, the club Martin Long supported and would later help chair.
What controversies has Churchill faced?
In January 2012 the Financial Services Authority fined Churchill and sister company Direct Line 2.17m pounds after finding that they had altered complaints files. In February 2013 the company drew media attention when it appealed against a High Court judgment in a case involving a 13-year-old struck by a car whose driver was one of its customers. It eventually paid 90% of the claim.
Which one suits a car insurance buyer?
The three do different jobs. A comparison site such as Confused.com or Go.Compare puts several insurance products in front of you at once, and the Go Compare vs Confused question comes down to emphasis: Confused.com was first and has long advertised with mascots and robots, while Go.Compare made a point of describing product features. Churchill car insurance is the opposite model, sold straight from the insurer with U K Insurance Limited behind the policy.
For anyone searching for UK car insurance comparison, the ownership picture is worth knowing too. Admiral built Confused.com and sold it to RVU, Future owns Go.Compare, and Churchill sits with Direct Line Group.
Where Go.Compare and Confused.com stand now
The dates ahead are modest. Go.Compare's Welsh Rugby Union deal runs for four years from its July 2023 announcement, and its brand work since 2024 aims to modernise the look and feel of the site. Confused.com has Steve Dukes at the helm since March 2023. Future now reports Go.Compare as its own segment, and its revenue in the year to 30 September 2025 slipped from 202.7 million pounds to 191.8 million.



