A $9 toll below 61st Street, a Swedish tax that is free in July, and the early evidence on whether charging drivers actually clears the streets.
New York's tolling program, begun 5 January 2025, charges drivers entering Manhattan south of 61st Street, with a $9 base toll. Stockholm taxed entry and exit from 2007 after a 2006 trial. Both cut traffic, though Stockholm's wider congestion rose five percent by 2012.
When Stockholm tried a congestion tax in 2006, the road authority reported that traffic across the charging cordon fell by between 20 and 25 percent. Yet from 2006 to 2012, despite less traffic and more favourable public opinion, congestion in the city rose by five percent. That mixed record is the first thing to know about road charging, and it sits behind the idea New York put into practice in January 2025, after becoming the first American city to enact it in 2019.
The two schemes make a revealing pair. One is a tax run through number plates and monthly bills; the other is a toll with a long political history, shaped by a governor, a mayor and a federal court. Between them they show why congestion pricing is widely copied and still argued over.
How does congestion pricing work in New York City?
New York City's scheme, formally the Central Business District Tolling Program, began on 5 January 2025. The zone, known as the Congestion Relief Zone, takes in nearly everything in Manhattan below 61st Street. Tolls are collected electronically, and the rate depends on the time of day, the type of vehicle and whether the vehicle has an E-ZPass transponder. A driver who sticks to FDR Drive or the West Side Highway pays nothing, and so does one who comes off the Brooklyn Bridge or Queensboro Bridge by the ramps that join those roads.
The aim is to push commuters towards public transport and cut traffic and pollution. By 2024, New York led the world in urban car congestion, despite its all-hours subway. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) estimates that bonding the toll revenue will make $15 billion of capital available for repairs and improvements to subway, bus and commuter rail.
New York congestion pricing: how much does it cost?
The Traffic Mobility Review Board recommended in November 2023 a base toll of $15 for passenger vehicles, charged once a day, with other classes of vehicle paying up to $36 and taxis and for-hire vehicles charged for each trip. In November 2024, the proposed passenger rate was cut to $9, still once a day.
Those rates run from 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday to Friday and from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. at weekends. At night the toll drops by 75 percent. Drivers without an E-ZPass pay 50 percent more than those with one, and an E-ZPass from any state qualifies for the standard rate. The MTA had the right to add up to 25 percent on "gridlock alert" days, but Governor Kathy Hochul told it in December 2024 not to. Drivers who come in through the four tunnels (Holland, Lincoln, Hugh L. Carey and Queens-Midtown) can receive a credit against the congestion toll. Bridges earn none, so a driver crossing the George Washington Bridge pays both charges in full. Only the first trip into the zone each day is charged.
Low-income residents get half off daytime tolls once they have made 10 trips into the zone in a calendar month. Exemptions are limited to a small group: commuter buses, emergency vehicles, specialised government vehicles and vehicles carrying disabled riders.
The cameras behind it
A ring of licence plate scanners watches every street leading into the zone. TransCore mounted them on signal poles and on arms stretching over the road, and they read E-ZPass tags while capturing infrared photographs of plates. Infrared was chosen over flash cameras to avoid light pollution in nearby neighbourhoods. Machine learning sorts vehicles into toll categories, and plates the system cannot read are checked by hand. Across 110 detection points there are more than 1,400 scanners, a third of them on existing walkways, overpasses and poles, with the rest on new gantries. Scanners over FDR Drive and the West Side Highway tell the system whether a vehicle stayed on those roads without entering the zone.
Traffic fell in both cities, though Stockholm's congestion still rose by five percent between 2006 and 2012.
A long road to the first toll
New York was a bridge-toll city once. The Brooklyn, Manhattan, Williamsburg and Queensboro bridges had tolls that were dropped before the Great Depression, and plans to revive them surfaced in 1933, 1952, 1966, 1968 and again in 1971. Under Mayor John Lindsay in the 1970s, the city wanted to limit cars in Lower Manhattan and toll the East River crossings, but Lindsay's successor Abraham Beame opposed the idea, and Ed Koch then tried to restore limits on vehicles entering Manhattan.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg proposed congestion pricing in 2007 as part of PlaNYC, and it stalled in the State Assembly. The New York Times later reflected that his 2008 version would have raised $500 million a year. Traffic commissioner Sam Schwartz tried again in 2015, with no legislation passing.
From Cuomo to the 2019 budget
The subway crisis of mid-2017 turned the argument. Governor Andrew Cuomo, who had doubted such a plan could work, called it an idea whose time had come, noting that London and Stockholm had done it successfully. He saw open road tolling, which records E-ZPass tags and plates without forcing cars to slow, as the difference from Bloomberg's day. New York then had the third worst congestion of any major city, behind Moscow and Los Angeles. A state task force, Fix NYC, took shape that October.
Its January 2018 report proposed charging cars up to $11.52, trucks up to $25.34 and taxis a $2 to $5 surcharge per trip in rush hours, with up to $1.5 billion a year in revenue. It also found that fewer than 5,000 of 118,000 outer-borough car commuters would count as working poor. The March 2018 budget left out the toll but added surcharges on trips below 96th Street: $2.50 for taxis, $2.75 for other for-hire cars and $0.75 per rider for ride-shares. In February 2019, Mayor Bill de Blasio and Cuomo agreed on a plan for the first time, and on 1 April 2019 the pricing law passed in the state budget, making New York the first US city to enact congestion pricing. It was handed to the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority to plan and run, with a Traffic Mobility Review Board of a chair and five members to recommend the tolls.
Delay, revival and a legal fight
Federal officials gave final approval in June 2023, but the rollout slipped several times. In June 2024 Hochul postponed it indefinitely, just before it was due to start. She revived it in November 2024 at a lower price. Soon after the toll began, President Donald Trump's administration withdrew federal approval, a step a federal judge found unlawful in a 2026 ruling.
Does congestion pricing work? New York's early results
Private vehicle traffic dropped at once, and journeys got quicker for buses and cars alike. Foot traffic and business inside the zone grew, collisions and pedestrian deaths fell, and air quality improved.
How the Stockholm congestion tax works
Stockholm's version, in Swedish Trangselskatt i Stockholm, taxes most vehicles entering and leaving the city centre. It followed a seven-month trial from 3 January to 31 July 2006 and became permanent on 1 August 2007. It drew inspiration from Singapore's Electronic Road Pricing system, whose origins lie in a 1975 scheme called the Area Licensing Scheme. The stated purpose is to reduce congestion and improve the environment, and the money goes to new road building in and around Stockholm.
The zone covers essentially the whole inner city: Sodermalm, Norrmalm, Ostermalm, Vasastaden, Kungsholmen, Stora Essingen, Lilla Essingen and Djurgarden. Unmanned control points sit at every entrance, and the tax applies on both entry and exit. Nothing is paid at the gantry, which only records passing vehicles. A bill goes to the owner each month, to be paid before the end of the following month, by post, internet bank or Autogiro direct debit. Miss the deadline and a reminder with a 500 SEK fee follows; if it is still unpaid 30 days later, the Swedish Enforcement Administration adds at least 600 SEK and records the owner in the Enforcement Register.
What Stockholm charges
The charge depends on the time of entry or exit. Nothing is levied on weekends, on public holidays or the day before one, overnight between 18:30 and 06:29, or in July. The tax first went up in January 2016, when the two busiest slots (7:30 to 8:29 in the morning and 16:00 to 17:29 in the afternoon) rose from SEK 20 to SEK 35, and the daily maximum became SEK 105 per vehicle. The motorway Essingeleden was brought into the scheme at the same time, with the extra money going towards the extension of the Stockholm Metro. Transport agencies expected a reduction of around 10 percent in peak traffic on the road, and a week after charging began traffic was 22 percent below a normal mid-December day.
Exemptions, deductions and foreign cars
Exempt vehicles include emergency services, buses of at least 14 tonnes, diplomatic and military vehicles, motorcycles and disabled-permit cars not used for work. Foreign-registered vehicles did not pay until 2014; they were let off for practical reasons, and the exemption ended after company objections and because an EU directive bars charges that discriminate by vehicle origin. Collection agencies now operate in the most common countries.
The tax can be deducted from taxable income. Businesses can deduct all of it, and private individuals can deduct it for business trips and for commuting when the distance is at least 5 km (3.1 mi) and the time saved over public transport is at least two hours a day, though a fixed initial slice of the cost cannot be deducted.
Stockholm's results and its critics
In the trial, the Road Administration reported a 20 to 25 percent fall in traffic across the cordon and better air quality, before volumes built up again. Some 96 percent of drivers paid on time, and the trial raised 399 million SEK. Voters in Stockholm municipality backed a permanent scheme in a referendum on 17 September 2006, though 14 other municipalities voted no. The parties that won the general election held the same day, led by what became the Reinfeldt cabinet, announced on 1 October 2006 that the tax would be permanent, with revenue switched to road building rather than public transport. The Riksdag approved it on 20 June 2007.
The argument cooled once the system worked smoothly, and many accepted the cost. Some critics shifted to politics, arguing that it punishes Stockholm residents or reflects rural resentment of the capital. A technical complaint concerns number plate recognition: plates from Finland, Lithuania and Hungary resemble Swedish ones, three letters and three digits, so a Swedish owner might be charged wrongly. Stolen and forged plates have produced false demands too, and anyone who objects has the charge cancelled, because every vehicle is photographed.
| Feature | New York City | Stockholm |
|---|---|---|
| Started | 5 January 2025 | Trial 3 January 2006; permanent 1 August 2007 |
| Area | Manhattan south of 61st Street | Central Stockholm, plus Essingeleden since 2016 |
| Charge | $9 base for passenger vehicles, once a day | SEK 20 to SEK 35 at peaks, up to SEK 105 a day |
| Quiet times | 75 percent less at night | No charge at night, weekends, holidays or in July |
| Collection | E-ZPass or plate scan, billed to owner | Plate recognition, monthly bill |
| Revenue goes to | MTA capital for subway, bus and rail | New roads, plus Metro extension from 2016 |
| Reported effect | Less traffic, faster journeys, fewer collisions | 20 to 25 percent less cordon traffic in the trial |
What it means if you drive into either city
In New York, a driver without an E-ZPass pays half as much again, a night-time trip costs a quarter of the daytime rate, and the toll is charged once per day however many times the car enters. In Stockholm the cost depends on the minute you pass the gantry, a trip in July or at the weekend is free, and the bill arrives by post at the end of the month. A missed bill in Stockholm costs 500 SEK extra, and a foreign-registered car is billed just like a Swedish one.
Where this goes next
The MTA expects to bond the New York toll revenue to produce $15 billion in available capital for the transit system. The MTA also kept the option of moving the base toll by as much as 10 percent for a year at a time. In Stockholm, the 2016 changes were meant to support the extension of the Metro, and the transport agencies expected peak traffic on Essingeleden to fall by roughly 10 percent.





