Storing Braking Energy in Flywheels and Supercapacitors
Features

Flywheels and Supercapacitors Store Energy Fast but Pose Problems in Cars

Photo: Unknown, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons · Source

A spinning rotor and a charged sponge: two ways to hold and release energy in seconds, and the trouble each causes on the road.

FeaturesBy 9 min read
The short answer

A flywheel stores energy in a spinning rotor, while a supercapacitor stores charge in a double layer at its electrodes. Both can take and release energy quickly, but flywheels bring gyroscopic and containment problems, and supercapacitors suit short bursts such as regenerative braking.

A modern flywheel can spin at more than 50,000 rpm inside a vacuum on magnetic bearings, store a useful charge in minutes and last for decades. It can also, if its outer binding fails, shatter and release every joule of stored energy at once, with fragments that can hit with the punch of a bullet. That tension, between what a spinning wheel can store and what it can do when it lets go, runs through the whole story of flywheels.

How does flywheel energy storage work?

A flywheel stores energy by spinning a rotor. Put energy in and the wheel speeds up; take energy out and it slows, in line with conservation of energy. A child's roundabout does the same thing: push it and it keeps going, and the faster it turns, the more energy it holds. Flywheel designs differ in how they get there. Some use light rotors that spin extremely fast, while grid-scale systems use enormous rotors, perhaps 200 tonnes, turning much more slowly. Others spin their rotors at many tens of thousands of rpm.

Most flywheel systems use electricity to speed the wheel up and slow it down, through a motor-generator connected to the rotor. Devices that use mechanical energy directly are being developed. A typical system has the flywheel on rolling-element bearings, and the wheel, sometimes with the motor-generator, may sit in a vacuum chamber to cut friction and energy loss.

From steel wheels to carbon fibre

First-generation flywheels were large steel wheels on mechanical bearings. Newer ones use carbon-fibre composite rotors, which have higher tensile strength than steel and hold far more energy for a given weight. Advanced systems suspend the rotor on magnetic bearings and spin it at 20,000 to over 50,000 rpm in a vacuum enclosure. Such a wheel is up to speed within minutes, filling its energy capacity far more quickly than some other storage methods.

Materials and shape set the ceiling. Maximum specific energy depends on the rotor's geometry and the properties of its material: the stronger and lighter the material, the more energy it can hold. A shape factor, K, describes the geometry. The theoretical best, a constant-stress disc, has K equal to 1. A constant-thickness disc is 0.606, a thin cylinder 0.5 and a rod 0.333. Most flywheels with a shaft sit at or below 0.333, while a shaft-less design is close to a plain disc at about 0.6, which enables a doubled energy density. Certain composites can exceed 400 Wh/kg in strength-to-density terms, which is why advanced flywheels use them. Beacon Power and Phillips Service Industries (PowerThru) have used carbon-fibre composites, whereas Calnetix uses aerospace-grade high-performance steel.

Flywheel: carbon-fibre rotor on magnetic bearings in a vacuum chamber, with a motor-generator20,000 to over 50,000 rpmVacuum chamberPower in and outMagnetic bearingsCarbon-fibre rotorMotor-generator
A carbon-fibre rotor turns on magnetic bearings in a vacuum chamber, and a motor-generator puts power in and takes it out.
All that internal surface gives the charge somewhere to sit: think of a sponge.

Flywheel vs battery: how the numbers compare

Next to other ways of storing electricity, flywheels have long lives, running for decades with little or no upkeep. Specific energy is quoted at 100 to 130 W-h/kg (360 to 500 kJ/kg), and maximum power output is large. Round-trip efficiency, the energy that comes out divided by the energy that went in, can be as high as 90 per cent. Typical capacities run from 3 kWh to 133 kWh, and rapid charging takes under 15 minutes.

Those headline specific energies can mislead, though: commercial systems that have actually been built achieve much less, for example 11 W-h/kg (40 kJ/kg).

Efficiency also hinges on the bearings. Flywheels on mechanical bearings can shed 20 to 50 per cent of their charge within two hours. Much of that friction comes from the Earth's rotation: as the planet turns, the flywheel's orientation changes, much as a Foucault pendulum's swing plane appears to, and the flywheel's gyroscopic forces push back against its bearings. Aligning the spin axis with the Earth's axis avoids this. By contrast, flywheels on magnetic bearings in a high vacuum can maintain 97 per cent mechanical efficiency and 85 per cent round-trip efficiency.

What happens when a flywheel fails

The main limit on any flywheel is the tensile strength of its rotor. A stronger disc can be spun faster and store more. Adding weight without adding strength only lowers the maximum safe speed, so it does not raise the energy stored.

When the binding cover of a composite flywheel exceeds its tensile strength, the cover fractures and the wheel shatters as the compression around its circumference is lost. All the stored energy goes at once, which is why this is called a flywheel explosion. Composites that are wound and bonded in layers break up fast: first into fine filaments that tangle and slow one another, then into a red-hot powder. A cast metal wheel is worse in one respect, because it hurls out big pieces of fast-moving shrapnel. Aluminium is especially prone to fatigue, developing microfractures after many small stretching cycles.

The answer is containment. Traditional systems need strong vessels, which adds mass, and a gel or encapsulated liquid lining can soak up some of the energy of a failure by boiling. Many customers of large flywheel systems still prefer to bury them in the ground to stop anything that escapes the vessel.

Flywheels in cars: the gyroscope problem

A flywheel in a vehicle is also a gyroscope. Its angular momentum is typically comparable in size to the forces acting on a moving vehicle, so it can affect handling in corners or on rough ground. Drive onto the side of a slope and the wheel's resistance to sideways tilt may partly lift tyres off the road. The same property could be put to work to keep a car balanced in sharp turns and stop it rolling over.

A flywheel used purely for its effect on a vehicle's attitude, instead of for storing energy, is called a reaction wheel or control moment gyroscope. For energy storage, designers need to isolate it from the car's movements, and gimbals do that. The centre axle of the flywheel acts as one gimbal, and if it is vertical it allows 360 degrees of yaw. Driving uphill needs a second, pitch gimbal, and driving on a sloped embankment needs a third, roll gimbal. The trouble is gimbal lock, so a compromise is needed between the number of gimbals and the freedom they give.

  • A full-motion gimbal needs a spherical space for the wheel to turn in, and slip rings on every axis to carry power in and out, which adds complexity.
  • A limited-motion gimbal uses shock absorbers to cushion sudden movements within about 30 degrees of pitch and roll either way, then gently pushes the flywheel to match the vehicle's orientation.
  • Another idea is two joined flywheels spinning in opposite directions, giving zero angular momentum and no gyroscopic effect. Unless both are held at exactly the same speed, though, the housing is subject to torque, and strictly speaking the two wheels exert a huge twisting moment at the centre that tries to bend the axle.

What is a supercapacitor?

A supercapacitor, also called an ultracapacitor, is a capacitor with enormous capacitance compared with a solid-state one, at the price of lower voltage limits. It sits between electrolytic capacitors and rechargeable batteries. Per unit of mass or volume it typically holds 10 to 100 times the energy of an electrolytic capacitor; compared with a battery, it takes and gives charge far faster and survives many more charge-discharge cycles.

Unlike ordinary capacitors, supercapacitors have no conventional solid dielectric. Energy is held by two mechanisms, electrostatic double-layer capacitance and electrochemical pseudocapacitance, and both add to the total. Inside, two electrodes are separated by an ion-permeable membrane and joined by an electrolyte. When voltage is applied, ions in the electrolyte gather at each electrode in layers of opposite polarity, separated by only a few angstroms (0.3 to 0.8 nm), far less than in a conventional capacitor. The electrodes are usually carbon, such as activated charcoal, a spongy, intensely porous form of carbon. Think of a sponge: all that internal surface gives the charge somewhere to sit.

Where supercapacitors are used

Supercapacitors suit jobs that need many rapid charge and discharge cycles, not long-term compact storage. Cars, buses, trains, cranes and lifts use them to recover braking energy, hold power for short periods and deliver it in bursts. Smaller units back up the memory of SRAM chips.

Flywheel and supercapacitor side by side

FeatureFlywheelSupercapacitor
How energy is storedKinetic energy of a spinning rotorCharge in a double layer at the electrodes
Compared with a batteryLong lifetime, large maximum power, charges in under 15 minutesTakes and gives charge much faster; many more cycles
Typical roleGrid-scale and high-speed systemsRegenerative braking and short bursts in vehicles and cranes
Main drawbackFailure releases all stored energy; gyroscopic effects in vehiclesSuited to many quick cycles, not long-term compact storage
Charge speed and efficiencyCharges in under 15 minutes; up to 85% round trip with magnetic bearings in a vacuumAccepts and delivers charge much faster than a battery

A short history of the supercapacitor

General Electric engineers started experimenting with porous carbon electrodes in the early 1950s, an offshoot of their fuel cell and battery work. In 1957 H. Becker patented a low-voltage capacitor built around porous carbon electrodes. He did not know how it worked; the patent admits it was unclear exactly what was taking place, but that the capacity was extremely high. General Electric did not pursue the idea at first. In 1966 researchers at Standard Oil of Ohio, known as SOHIO, built another version while working on fuel cells, and in 1970 Donald L. Boos patented one that was still filed as an electrolytic capacitor using activated carbon.

The early designs used two aluminium foils covered in activated carbon, soaked in electrolyte, with a thin porous insulator between them, and delivered a capacitance of about one farad. That basic design still underlies most electrochemical capacitors. SOHIO licensed the technology to NEC, which marketed it as the supercapacitor in 1978 to back up computer memory. Panasonic launched its Goldcaps around the same time, and ELNA entered in 1987.

Between 1975 and 1980 Brian Evans Conway carried out the fundamental work on ruthenium oxide electrochemical capacitors, and in 1999 he defined the term supercapacitor for devices whose capacitance is increased by surface redox reactions. The first supercapacitor with low internal resistance came in 1982 through the Pinnacle Research Institute for military use, and in 1992 Maxwell Laboratories took over the development and called its products Boost Caps to stress their use for power. In 1994 David A. Evans built a hybrid called the Capattery, with about five times the energy content of a comparable tantalum electrolytic capacitor, though its high cost restricted it to military uses. Fujitsu's FDK pioneered lithium-ion capacitors in 2007.

Where this goes next

For flywheels, the open question is bearings. High-temperature superconductor bearings may be economical and could extend the time energy can be stored economically; hybrid bearings, with permanent magnets carrying the load and superconductors stabilising it, are most likely to be used first. Larger designs still need a way to stop the levitation force fading and the rotor slowly sinking because of flux creep. Superconductors are also used cautiously because of vibration along the rotational axis, which prevents fully superconducting magnetic bearings.

For supercapacitors, labs in companies and universities alike are chasing better specific energy, specific power and cycle stability, at lower cost.

What it means for a buyer or a driver

Supercapacitors are already used in automobiles, buses and trains for regenerative braking and short bursts of power, because they take up and release charge quickly and survive many cycles. A flywheel's difficulty in a road vehicle is its own gyroscopic behaviour, which is why designs rely on gimbals or counter-rotating pairs. If you meet either in a brochure, read it as a way of handling braking energy and power bursts.

Frequently asked questions

How does a flywheel store energy?
It spins a rotor. Adding energy makes the wheel spin faster and extracting energy slows it, in line with conservation of energy. Advanced versions use carbon-fibre rotors on magnetic bearings in a vacuum.
How does a supercapacitor differ from a battery?
It stores charge in an electric double layer at the electrodes instead of through chemical reactions in bulk material. It accepts and delivers charge much faster than a battery and survives many more cycles.
Why do flywheels need strong containment?
If the tensile strength of a rotor is exceeded, it can shatter and release all stored energy at once. Fragments can carry kinetic energy comparable to a bullet, so containment vessels are fitted and big systems are often buried.
Why are flywheels a problem in vehicles?
A spinning flywheel acts as a gyroscope, resisting tilting. It can upset handling in turns or on slopes, so designs use gimbals or pairs of flywheels spinning in opposite directions.
Where are supercapacitors used in cars and trains?
They are used in automobiles, buses, trains, cranes and elevators for regenerative braking, short-term energy storage and burst-mode power delivery, where many rapid charge and discharge cycles are needed.

Sources

  1. Flywheel energy storage - Wikipedia
  2. Supercapacitor - Wikipedia
Next story / Features

Crosley, Muntz Jet, Allstate and Bradley GT Ended Between 1952 and 1981