The Inverter and the Silicon Carbide Chips Inside an Electric Car
Features

EV Inverters Turn Battery DC Into AC and Silicon Carbide Aims to Cut Waste

Photo: Claus Ableiter, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Source · Licence

A box that makes no power of its own decides how efficiently an electric motor spins. What it does, the switches inside it, and why silicon carbide is the next candidate.

FeaturesBy 9 min read
The short answer

An EV inverter turns the battery's direct current, at 300 to 800 V, into alternating current for the motor and sets its speed by varying frequency. IGBTs are the switches; silicon carbide, a wide-bandgap material, tolerates about 300 C against silicon's 100 C and is expected to cut energy loss.

An inverter produces no power at all. Everything it hands to the motor of an electric car has already been supplied by the battery as direct current, and the inverter simply reshapes it. That makes the small box of switches between pack and motor an odd kind of hero: it cannot add energy, only waste less of it.

What does an inverter do between battery and motor?

A power inverter is an electronic device or circuit that changes direct current (DC) into alternating current (AC). It is the reverse of a rectifier, which turns AC into DC. The AC frequency that comes out depends on the particular device, and the power always comes from the DC source. A static inverter has no moving parts in the conversion.

An electric car's battery pack supplies DC at 300 to 800 V, and the motor wants AC. The inverter's task is to produce it, and, in a motor controller, to vary it. An ordinary mains inverter holds its output at 50 or 60 hertz. A variable frequency drive does the opposite. It changes the frequency on purpose, because a different frequency means a different motor speed. Inverter circuits designed to give a range of output voltages are widely used in motor speed controllers, and control and feedback circuitry adjusts the final output, which ultimately sets the speed of the motor under its mechanical load. Electric vehicles are among the uses, alongside industrial equipment, rail transport and power tools.

The same idea shows up at home. An inverter compressor in an air conditioner uses a variable-frequency drive to set how fast the compressor motor turns, in place of the older method of switching a single-speed compressor on and off.

How does it shape the current?

The trick is rapid switching. Adjusting the ratio of on time to off time, at a constant frequency, changes the effective voltage, and the technique is called pulse-width modulation, or PWM. Imagine dimming a lamp by flicking it on and off faster than the eye can follow: the longer each on period, the brighter it looks. Gate pulses go to each switch in a developed pattern to obtain the output wanted.

Some inverters use PWM to build a waveform which a low-pass filter can turn back into a sine wave. They need only one DC supply, but the switching runs far faster, typically many kilohertz, so the changing pulse widths can be smoothed out. If a microprocessor generates the switching timing, the harmonic content and the efficiency can be closely controlled.

Why waveform quality costs efficiency

An inverter can produce a square wave, a sine wave, a modified sine wave, a pulsed sine wave or a near-sine PWM wave. One measure of how pure a sine wave is, is total harmonic distortion, or THD. A square wave at a 50% duty cycle carries about 48.3% THD relative to the underlying sine wave. A modified sine wave stacks two square waves, offsetting one by a quarter of a period, and its lowest THD is 30%, reached when the pulses are 130 degrees wide in each electrical cycle. Grid standards require less than 3% THD at the customer's connection point, and IEEE Standard 519 recommends less than 5% for systems that connect to a grid. Waveforms with more steps approximate the sine wave better, but they need extra switching components and cost more.

For a motor, distortion matters. An AC motor fed straight from a non-sinusoidal supply can run hotter, behave differently in speed and torque, and sound louder. Most AC motors will run on a modified sine wave inverter with an efficiency reduction of about 20% because of the harmonic content, although they may be quite noisy. In induction motors the voltage harmonics normally do not matter, but distortion in the current waveform adds heating and can create pulsating torques. A manufacturer's nominal conversion efficiency also does not take harmonics into account, so a pure sine wave inverter can be significantly more efficient overall than a modified one.

BatteryDC 300 to 800 VInverterIGBT or SiCMotorACPulse-width modulationSine wave
The inverter turns the battery's DC into AC for the motor by switching rapidly, and pulse-width modulation shapes the pulses into a sine wave.
An inverter cannot add a single watt. It can only waste fewer of them.

What is an IGBT?

An insulated-gate bipolar transistor, or IGBT, is a power semiconductor with three terminals, used chiefly as an electronic switch. Its designers wanted high efficiency and fast switching in one device. It is built from four alternating layers, labelled NPNP, controlled by a metal-oxide-semiconductor gate. It resembles a thyristor in structure, but the thyristor action is completely suppressed so that only transistor action takes place across the whole operating range.

The attraction is that it joins the strengths of two older devices: the simple gate drive of a power MOSFET and the high-current, low-saturation-voltage capability of a bipolar transistor. Large IGBT modules typically combine many devices in parallel, with current-handling capability in the hundreds of amperes and blocking voltages of 6500 V, and they can control loads of hundreds of kilowatts. Because an IGBT turns on and off quickly, it can build complex waveforms from PWM pulses and low-pass filtering, and modern devices switch at rates well into the ultrasonic range. It is used in variable-frequency drives for motor control in trains and electric cars, as well as in refrigerators, air conditioners, welding machines, solar inverters and uninterruptible power supplies.

By 2010 only the power MOSFET was more widely used among power transistors. Within the power transistor market it held 27%, the MOSFET 53%, the RF amplifier 11% and the bipolar junction transistor 9%.

How the IGBT grew up

The path was slow. The bipolar point-contact transistor was invented at Bell Telephone Laboratories in December 1947, and the MOSFET came later at Bell Labs, between 1959 and 1960. Mitsubishi Electric's K. Yamagami and Y. Akagiri filed a Japanese patent in 1968 that first described the basic IGBT mode, a pnp transistor driven by a MOSFET. A patent from J. D. Plummer and B. Scharf in 1978 covered a device mixing MOS and bipolar abilities.

The great obstacle was latch-up, in which a parasitic thyristor inside the four-layer structure could destroy the device. B. Jayant Baliga reported a practical device in 1982, and General Electric commercialised it that year. A. Nakagawa and colleagues completely suppressed the parasitic thyristor in 1984 by setting the saturation current below the latch-up current, and Toshiba first commercialised non-latch-up products in 1985. The first-generation devices of the 1980s and early 1990s were still prone to latch-up and to secondary breakdown, in which a hotspot burns the device out. The third-generation IGBTs of today have speed rivalling power MOSFETs together with excellent ruggedness, and the IGBT has been described as the most rugged and strongest power device yet developed.

IGBT or MOSFET, which switch suits which job?

FeatureIGBTPower MOSFET
Forward voltage at high blocking voltageSignificantly lowerHigher
Forward voltage at low current densityDiode-like drop, typically about 2 VMuch lower, behaves like a resistance
Reverse currentCannot conduct; needs a freewheeling diodeCan conduct
Switching speed and lossLonger switching times, higher switching lossFaster, lower switching loss
Favoured conditionsHigh voltage, high current, lower frequenciesLow voltage, medium current, high switching frequencies

The reason lies in the silicon. As a device is rated for higher blocking voltage, its drift region must grow deeper and more lightly doped, and a MOSFET's forward drop climbs steeply. The IGBT gets around this by injecting holes from the collector layer into the drift region while it conducts, which sharply cuts the region's resistance. The price is a set of penalties. The extra junction blocks reverse current, so a bridge circuit needs a freewheeling diode alongside. The reverse bias rating is usually only tens of volts, so a circuit that might apply reverse voltage needs a series diode. And the injected carriers take time to arrive and leave, which lengthens switching and raises switching loss. None of this is overly severe, since at the higher voltages where IGBTs dominate, discrete diodes outperform the body diode of a MOSFET.

What is a wide-bandgap semiconductor?

Every semiconductor has a bandgap, the energy an electron must gain to move into a state where it can carry current. Conventional semiconductors such as silicon, germanium and selenium have bandgaps in the range of 0.7 to 1.5 electronvolts (eV), while wide-bandgap materials sit above 2 eV, typically from 2 to 4 eV.

An everyday picture helps. In a semiconductor, a small input of energy pushes electrons into the conduction band and lets current flow like a conductor, while reversing the polarity pushes them back into the widely separated band and turns the material into an insulator. Because the energy needed for the jump is small, switching costs very little. The same smallness is the weakness: temperature also shifts the balance of electrons between the two states, so a hot device may switch on its own, or stop switching at all.

The size of that gap sets how easily heat can switch a device on by accident. A small bandgap means a chip can be controlled by relatively low voltages, but it is also readily activated by thermal energy, and that interferes with its proper operation. It limits silicon devices to temperatures below about 100 C. A wide bandgap raises the ceiling on the order of 300 C, so wide-bandgap devices can run at much higher power levels in ordinary use.

They bring other advantages. Most wide-bandgap materials have a critical electric field about ten times that of conventional semiconductors, which lets them operate at much higher voltages and currents, and their high free-electron velocities allow faster switching. Strong atomic bonds also mean higher melting temperatures and high thermal conductivity, so heat is easily removed. Within group IV of the periodic table, diamond and silicon carbide (SiC) are the sole wide-bandgap materials; gallium nitride, aluminium nitride and boron nitride belong to the III-V family.

Why silicon carbide matters for an inverter

Power transistors built on silicon are nearing their ceilings for operating frequency, breakdown voltage and power density. Gallium nitride and silicon carbide are tough materials that suit high power and high temperature. Given that toughness and an easy manufacturing process, silicon carbide chips are expected to find wide use. Among the expected benefits are simpler charging with higher efficiency for hybrid and all-electric vehicles, reduced energy loss, longer-lasting solar and wind power converters, and the elimination of bulky grid substation transformers. The US Department of Energy believes wide-bandgap materials will underpin tough, efficient power parts for high-power vehicles, a range running from plug-in electric cars up to electric trains.

The link to efficiency runs through heat. An inverter wastes energy when its switches lose power as heat, and silicon carbide is expected to reduce energy loss because it tolerates higher temperatures, higher voltages and faster switching, in a material from which heat is easily removed.

What this means for an electric car owner

The inverter's switches decide how cleanly the motor receives its current, and the waveform they produce sets how much extra heating and noise the motor suffers. A more efficient inverter wastes less of the battery's energy before it reaches the motor. The wide-bandgap case rests on what the chips tolerate: heat, voltage and switching speed.

Where this goes next

The expectation is that silicon carbide will spread, but the position today is still mixed. Most wide-bandgap devices go into specialist equipment for space programmes and the military, and silicon still leads the general power semiconductor market. Development of wide-bandgap materials also trails that of conventional semiconductors, which have attracted heavy investment since the 1970s. Their advantages have nonetheless led to rising interest in using them in everyday electronic devices in place of silicon, and the US Department of Energy expects them to become foundational for power components across a range of vehicles, plug-in electric cars and electric trains included.

Frequently asked questions

What does an inverter do in an electric car?
It changes the direct current from the battery, at 300 to 800 V DC, into alternating current for the motor. Varying the frequency and voltage through pulse-width modulation controls the speed of the motor.
What kind of switch is an IGBT?
An insulated-gate bipolar transistor is a three-terminal power semiconductor used mainly as a fast electronic switch. It combines the simple gate drive of a MOSFET with the high-current capability of a bipolar transistor, and it is used in motor drives for electric cars and trains.
What makes a semiconductor wide-bandgap?
It is a semiconductor with a bandgap above 2 eV, compared with 0.7 to 1.5 eV for silicon. That lets devices work at much higher voltages, frequencies and temperatures. Silicon carbide and gallium nitride are examples.
How does silicon carbide compare with silicon?
Silicon devices are limited to temperatures below about 100 C, while wide-bandgap devices can operate on the order of 300 C. Silicon carbide is expected to bring simpler, more efficient charging and reduced energy loss, but it has not yet displaced silicon in the general power market.
IGBT or MOSFET, which is better?
It depends on the job. The IGBT suits high voltage, high current and lower frequencies; the MOSFET is the choice when voltage is low, current moderate and switching frequency high.

Sources

  1. Power inverter - Wikipedia
  2. Insulated-gate bipolar transistor - Wikipedia
  3. Wide-bandgap semiconductor - Wikipedia
Next story / Features

Car Electronics at 30% of a Car's Value, UDS Diagnostics and OSEK Software