Features

Lease or Buy a Car, and How Hire Purchase, PCP and Novated Leases Differ

Leasing, hire purchase, PCP balloon payments and novated leases all promise a monthly figure. The difference is what you hold, and owe, when the term ends.

FeaturesBy 11 min read
The short answer

A lease lets you use a car for a fixed term and return it or buy it at a set residual value. Hire purchase makes you the owner only after the final instalment. A PCP lowers monthly payments and ends in a balloon payment. A novated lease is an Australian salary packaging route.

In a hire purchase deal you do not own the car you are driving. You hire it, month after month, and only the last instalment turns that hire into a sale. Lease, hire purchase, personal contract purchase and the Australian novated lease all put a car on your driveway for a monthly payment, yet they split sharply on who holds the title, what you owe at the end and who carries the risk if the car is worth less than predicted.

Lease or buy a car: where the real difference sits

A lease is the use of a vehicle for a fixed period at an agreed price. Dealers offer it as an alternative to buying, and businesses lean on it heavily because it avoids the large cash outlay. The usual primary term is two, three or four years, and when it ends the car either goes back to the leasing company or is bought for its residual value.

That residual figure is the whole game. Almost every lease fixes a purchase price for the end of the term in advance. If the car turns out to be worth more than the prediction, the lessee can buy it and pocket the gap. If it is worth less, the lessee hands it back and walks away. An owner who bought outright carries that future-value worry alone; a lessee does not.

Lease payments are usually lower than the payments on a car loan for the same vehicle. In most US states, sales tax falls due on each monthly payment rather than on the full price at the start, as it would with an instalment sale or a loan. Over the life of the lease, the consumer pays less sales tax than a buyer would.

A lessee can also move into a new car every few years without the negative equity that can bite when a purchased car is traded in after two or three years. The car is, in theory, always inside the factory warranty, so repairs are not the lessee's bill, provided it is serviced to the maker's recommendations.

The seller has reasons to like it too. The maker's finance arm still owns the car and can lease it again or remarket it, and lessees come back to the showroom sooner and stay loyal to the same maker.

In the termAt the endLeaseThe lessor owns itReturn it or buyHire purchaseOwner keeps titleBuy or return itPCPLegal ownerPay the balloonNovated leaseThe lessor owns itPay the residual
How the four car finance routes differ on who holds the car during the term and what the driver does at the end.
A lease hands the guess about the car's future value to the owner. A PCP leaves it with you until the balloon falls due.

How does a car lease work in practice?

Payments are worked out much like loan payments, except that the lender quotes a money factor in place of an APR. Contracts typically run from 24 months up to 60 months, and the end-of-term price is usually agreed at signing.

Then come the limits. A mileage allowance is written in, and 10,000 miles a year is a common figure for passenger cars, though the customer can set it anywhere from 5,000 to 25,000 miles a year. Go over, and fees may apply. Dealers will usually negotiate a higher allowance, at the price of a higher payment. The contract also spells out how much wear is acceptable, with a charge if the car comes back in worse shape, and it normally carries an early termination fee.

A newer twist is the flexi-lease. A driver takes a new vehicle for three months, then hands it back or extends. It sits close to van hire, except that the leasing company maintains the vehicle.

Europe has a 50-year-old short-term version. Renault Eurodrive lets non-European residents take a brand new car free of VAT, registered in their own name, with full risk insurance and 24 hour assistance included. At the end of the stay the driver returns the car and owes nothing more.

Hire purchase: the 19th-century fix for a cash shortage

Hire purchase, also called an instalment plan, was developed in the United Kingdom in the 19th century so that people short of cash could make an expensive purchase they would otherwise have delayed or abandoned. The buyer pays an initial instalment, for example 40 percent of the total, then repays the balance plus interest over a set period. Related practices go by the names closed-end leasing and rent-to-own.

The mechanics are simple. The buyer hires the goods for a monthly rent. When the payments add up to the full price plus interest, the buyer may exercise an option to buy at a predetermined price, usually a nominal sum, or give the goods back. If the buyer stops paying, the owner may repossess, a protection that unsecured consumer credit does not give a lender.

What a hire purchase contract must say

To be valid, an agreement must be in writing and signed by both sides. It has to describe the goods, give the cash price and the hire purchase price (the total payable to hire and then own), state the deposit and the monthly instalments, and set out the parties' rights, sometimes including a cooling-off period.

Who is the owner, and who is liable?

Most sellers want cash straight away, so they pass the goods to a finance company, which then hires and sells to the buyer. If the seller made false claims about the goods, the party who ends up selling is not the one who made them. To close the gap, some jurisdictions, Ireland among them, make the seller and the finance house jointly and severally liable.

The hirer can usually buy early by giving notice and paying the balance less a rebate, or return the goods subject to a penalty capped by law. In return the hirer must keep paying and take reasonable care. On default, the owner can forfeit the deposit, keep the instalments already paid, recover the balance, repossess (sometimes only through a court) and claim damages.

Hire purchase in Australia and Malaysia

In Australia, companies, partnerships and sole traders use it to fund cars and commercial vehicles, and it is often called commercial or corporate hire purchase. Businesses that account for GST on an accruals basis can claim an Input Tax Credit for all the GST in the price on their next Business Activity Statement. Les Meteyard and a business partner brought it to the country in the early 1960s.

Malaysia regulates it under the Hire Purchase Act 1967, in force from 11 April 1968. Cars are the most common subject, with repayment up to 9 years.

PCP explained: the balloon payment car loan

A personal contract purchase, also sold as a personal contract plan, is a form of hire purchase for individual buyers. It is common in the UK and Ireland and rare in many other countries. Instead of equal payments that clear the whole debt, the customer pays a lower amount each month over a term of usually 24 to 48 months and then faces a final balloon payment.

The borrowing is the same as in a traditional hire purchase deal, and interest runs on the entire amount, balloon included. The balloon is planned to sit below the car's expected value at the end, leaving equity that can serve as a deposit on the next car. That outcome is not guaranteed.

Unlike a lease, a PCP makes the customer the registered keeper and legal owner, while the finance company retains an interest. The interest appears in the car's history whenever anyone checks, so the car cannot be sold until the finance is cleared, and the lender can repossess on default. At the end there are two paths: pay the balloon and keep the car, or return it with no further liability.

How the balloon is set

The finance company calculates the final payment at the start from its estimate of the car's future residual value, called the Guaranteed Minimum Future Value. It is usually taken by direct debit unless the customer acts first. Some contracts make the balloon compulsory but let the owner hand the car back at the agreed figure instead. Legally, this is packaged as a call option to buy at a set price or a put option to sell at a set price.

The monthly payment comes from two levers: the deposit, which can be negotiated, and the balloon, which the finance company sets. A dealer or broker usually stands in for the finance company in the talks. Maintenance is included in only a minority of deals, while the majority in the UK cover the first year's Vehicle Excise Duty.

The UK and Irish picture

The model began with businesses. In 2016, 82 percent of personal new car finance deals in the UK were PCPs. As a conditional sale, a PCP is covered in the UK by the Consumer Credit Act 1974 and the Financial Services Regulations 2004. VAT applies to the entire vehicle price and is built into the monthly payment, whereas in personal contract hire the lessee pays VAT on the monthly payment.

Ireland has watched the product closely since 2014, when customers felt too little effort had gone into making sure they understood every detail of their agreements. Motorcheck had found that 73,979 new vehicles were sold on finance in Ireland in 2016, a rise of 139 percent on 2014.

Novated lease: the Australian salary packaging route

To novate a lease is to transfer its obligations from one party to another. In Australia the phrase refers almost exclusively to salary packaging a car. A three-way deed links the employee (the lessee), the lessor (usually a finance company) and the employer, who agrees to make the rental payments and gains the use of the vehicle on paper. In practice the employee drives it.

The employer usually covers the running costs too, such as fuel, insurance, registration and servicing, and then reduces the employee's salary by the total cost. Because that reduction comes out before income tax, the employee pays less tax and hopes to come out ahead. If the employee leaves the job, the novation ends and every obligation reverts to the employee, though the lease can be novated to a new employer.

The name causes confusion. People say novated lease for the whole package, yet the lease is only one part, and a so-called leasing company is often a salary packaging manager rather than the finance company that owns the car.

The tax mechanics

A car provided this way is a fringe benefit, and the employer may owe fringe benefits tax at a rate equal to the highest marginal income tax rate. Cars get concessional treatment: instead of actual running costs, the benefit can be valued at 20 percent of the original purchase price less stamp duty, registration and compulsory third party insurance. The concession assumes some business use, although none is required. Amendments in 2022 exempt employers from the tax when the car is an eligible electric or plug-in hybrid vehicle.

The value can drop to two thirds on 1 April after four full years since the lessor bought the car, though most novated leases run five years or less. An employer registered for GST can also claim back the GST on running costs.

The employee contribution method lets the employee pay part of the running costs to offset the fringe benefit and wipe out the tax. It trims the income tax and GST benefits but cuts the net cost overall, and it only helps where the 20 percent valuation comes out lower than the actual running costs.

Residuals, and the GST claim that does not add up

At the end, the contract requires the employee to return the car, and often to make up any shortfall if market value is below the residual. The residual is an estimate written in at the start. Lessors work in finance, not in selling used cars, so contracts let the lessee pay a penalty equal to the residual for failing to return the car. That works as a purchase, and it is so common that employees may not realise they could simply return it.

No tax saving applies to the residual payment, so a low residual and a higher rent suit the employee better. For that reason the Australian Taxation Office restricts how low the residual may go, while allowing lower figures where a well considered and fair estimate of the end value supports them. Generally the market value exceeds the residual, and that difference is not subject to the fringe benefits tax.

Salary packaging advertising often says the employee saves the GST on the purchase price. The employee is not buying the car, though. The lessor buys it and claims the credit, and GST must then be charged on both the rent and the residual. Take a driveaway price of $57,000, made up of $55,000 for the car including $5000 in GST, plus $2000 in stamp duty. The lessor claims $5000 back. Lease it for 36 payments of $1100 (rent of $39,600) with a residual of $27,500, and the lessee pays a total of $6100 in GST, more than the original purchase carried. Employees can save the GST on running costs, but not both that and the GST in the purchase price.

Most employers hand the work to a salary packaging company, which arranges the lease and novation, handles the tax accounting and pays the running costs for a management fee. It may also receive rebates or commissions from suppliers.

Lease, hire purchase, PCP and novated lease compared

OptionWho holds the car in the termAt the endTypical termMainly found
LeaseThe lessor owns itReturn it, or buy at the residual valueUsually 2, 3 or 4 years; 24 to 60 monthsWidely, including the US
Hire purchaseThe owner keeps title until payments are completeBuy at a predetermined, usually nominal, price, or return itUp to 9 years in MalaysiaUK origin; Australia, Malaysia
PCPCustomer is registered keeper and legal owner; the finance company keeps an interestPay the balloon and own it, or return it with no further liabilityUsually 24 to 48 monthsUK, Ireland
Novated leaseThe lessor owns it; the employer pays through salary packagingReturn it, or pay the residualMost are 5 years or lessAustralia

Which driver each arrangement suits

A lease is built for the driver who wants a newer car every few years and no exposure to resale value. The cost of that freedom is the set of limits: mileage allowances, wear charges and termination fees.

Hire purchase fits the buyer who wants to end up owning the car and is content to spread the price. A PCP suits the individual who wants lower monthly payments and a choice at the end between paying the balloon and walking away; the catch is that interest runs on the whole sum, balloon included.

A novated lease is for an Australian employee whose employer takes part in salary packaging. Its benefit depends on tax treatment, and the contribution method and the residual both change the net cost.

Where this goes next

US leasing recovered from its slump in the 2008 financial crisis to a record retail share of 26.5 percent in February 2014, and by 2016 it accounted for about 25 percent of all vehicle sales. In Australia, the 2022 amendments mean eligible electric and plug-in hybrid cars attract no fringe benefits tax for the employer. In Ireland, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission began its look at the PCP market in July 2017.

Frequently asked questions

What is a balloon payment on a car?
It is the large final payment that follows lower monthly payments, as in a personal contract purchase. The finance company sets it at the start from its estimate of the car's future value. The customer pays it and keeps the car, or returns the car with no further liability.
Can you keep a leased car at the end?
Usually yes. Most leases fix a purchase price for the end of the term, so the lessee can buy the car at the residual value or return it. In an Australian novated lease, a penalty equal to the residual for not returning the car works as a purchase.
How is a PCP different from hire purchase?
Both are forms of vehicle finance on the same total borrowing. Hire purchase repays the whole debt in equal instalments, while a PCP lowers the monthly amount and leaves a final balloon payment. Interest in a PCP is charged on the entire amount, balloon included.
What is a novated lease?
It is a lease whose obligations are transferred to the employer under a three-way deed. In Australia it almost always means salary packaging a car, where the employer makes the payments and reduces the employee's salary by the total cost, lowering the employee's income tax.
Do you really save the GST on a novated lease?
Not on the purchase price. On a $57,000 driveaway car the lessee pays $6100 in GST over the lease, against $5000 in the original purchase. Employees can save GST on running costs, but not on both.

Sources

  1. Vehicle leasing - Wikipedia
  2. Hire purchase - Wikipedia
  3. Personal contract purchase - Wikipedia
  4. Novated lease - Wikipedia
Next story / Engines

Power Steering Explained: From Hydraulic Pumps to Steer-by-Wire