From a 1973 monopoly to a $1.2 billion dividend bill and a switch to no-fault cover, how ICBC and the three other public insurers work, and where Australia fits in.
Public auto insurance is compulsory car insurance run by the provincial government, used in British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Quebec. In British Columbia the Crown corporation ICBC sells the basic Autoplan package through independent brokers and competes with private firms only for optional cover.
In Canada, four provinces own their car insurer, and in one of them the government once took $1.2 billion out of it. That province is British Columbia, where ICBC began in 1973 as a non-profit monopoly and was turned by a 2010 amendment into the only public auto insurer in the country that was made to pay money into the treasury.
What is public auto insurance in Canada?
Public auto insurance is compulsory car insurance that a provincial government owns and runs. It operates in British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Quebec. The logic is simple: if the state forces motorists to buy cover, it should make sure they pay fair premiums and receive high-quality protection in return.
Governments have chased that goal through very different schemes, from full tort, where an injured driver sues the at-fault party, to full no-fault, where each person claims from their own insurer. Public insurers in Canada have historically been not-for-profit. British Columbia's ICBC is the lone departure: a 2010 amendment to its founding law let the provincial government order it to send dividends to the treasury.
Despite the entrance of several firms in the 1980s, 87% of British Columbians who bought additional coverage did so from ICBC in 2003.
Is public car insurance cheaper than private?
Nobody has settled the question. Arguments over public and private provision usually turn on price and on how claimants are treated, and whether one system is more efficient remains open.
Supporters of private insurance point to the discipline of competition. An open market, they say, forces providers to keep costs down and compete on price, which should mean lower premiums. Supporters of public insurance answer that private companies must also earn profits for their owners, so a non-profit body is more likely to charge less.
The same split shows up in how claims are handled. Private-sector advocates argue that insureds simply change provider if they feel mistreated, so competition pushes insurers to be fair. The counterargument is that every private insurer faces similar profit pressure and is similarly reluctant to pay out, so policyholders are poorly served whichever name they choose. A public insurer running to break even over the long run, on that view, has more room to compensate claimants fully.
Hard numbers do not rescue the debate, because comparing premiums across jurisdictions is awkward for several reasons. Insurance models differ. Minimum levels of mandated cover vary widely, even between provinces with similar models. What counts as medical cover in one place may not in another. Demographics and weather change both the cost of claims and how often crashes happen. And comparisons with other countries, the United States above all, are muddied by the fact that Canada's public healthcare system pays medical costs that American auto insurers would often carry. An analysis that hides its method, or leans on premium data gathered from several outside sources, is likely to be unreliable.
The studies that exist disagree. Work by the Consumers' Association of Canada found rates in the four public-provision provinces lower than in provinces with private systems. A 2011 survey from the Fraser Institute, a think-tank described as right-wing, put the priciest premiums in Ontario, British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, and three of those four run public insurers. A Deloitte analysis from 2015, done for Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI), reached the opposite verdict: the four public provinces were the cheapest.
How do the four public insurers differ?
| Province | Insurer | Created | Claims model |
|---|---|---|---|
| British Columbia | ICBC | 1973 | Tort with some no-fault accident benefits, moving to no-fault in 2021 |
| Saskatchewan | Saskatchewan Government Insurance (SGI) | 1945 | Choice of no-fault or tort; no-fault by default |
| Manitoba | Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI) | 1971 | No-fault, though economic losses beyond the benefits can be pursued in court |
| Quebec | Societe de l'assurance automobile du Quebec (SAAQ) | 1978, as the RAAQ | Pure no-fault with no option to sue; injuries only |
What does ICBC car insurance cover?
The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia is a provincial Crown corporation that provides vehicle insurance and driver's licences. The law requires its basic package, called Autoplan, on every vehicle that is registered in the province and driven or left on a public street there. Independent brokers sell it across British Columbia.
Autoplan bundles accident benefits, cover for legal liability to third parties and protection against under-insured motorists. It also includes inverse liability, which pays compensation if a driver is involved in a crash in a jurisdiction that forbids recovering losses from an at-fault driver.
ICBC also pays for physical rehabilitation such as physiotherapy for people hurt in crashes. Those treatments typically fall under its Enhanced Care model and are delivered through approved clinics across the province. The corporation funds counselling too, for clients who have been in a crash or lost a family member in one.
What is the history of ICBC?
The NDP government of Premier Dave Barrett created ICBC in 1973 to offer universal, affordable and compulsory public insurance on a non-profit basis. The opposition Social Credit Party resisted it at first, but ICBC proved popular and every government since has backed its continued existence.
At the start it held a monopoly on all auto insurance. In 1977 the province amended the enabling legislation so that private insurers could compete for optional, supplemental cover, among it collision, comprehensive and extended liability plans. ICBC kept its monopoly on basic insurance and still sells optional cover too. Several firms entered in the 1980s, yet 87% of British Columbians who bought additional coverage in 2003 did so from ICBC.
Its job description has grown steadily. It began as an insurer alone. Over time it picked up driver and vehicle licensing and registration, the CounterAttack drive against impaired driving, wider traffic safety work, oversight of commercial transport, fine collection and driver education.
Why did the BC government take dividends from ICBC?
In March 2010 the BC Liberal government of Christy Clark announced that ICBC must hand the province dividends of about $778 million across three years. That ended its life as a non-profit Crown corporation, and it left ICBC as the only for-profit public auto insurer in Canada. The dividends eventually totalled $1.2 billion.
The change worked through an amendment to the Insurance Corporation Act that let the Cabinet Committee compel specified payments into the provincial treasury. That arrangement arguably did serious damage to ICBC's finances, and it is blamed for a forecast of dramatic rate rises totalling over 40%.
The NDP reversed course after winning the 2017 provincial election. It passed legislation guaranteeing that ICBC's profits stay with the company and cannot be moved to the provincial government.
How has ICBC changed since 2016?
The changes came quickly. On 23 November 2016 the provincial government announced that luxury cars, meaning those worth over $150,000, would no longer be insured by ICBC. About 3000 cars fell into that class, and the government claimed the move would save roughly $2.3 million a year. High-end dealers objected, saying the answer was to change what those owners pay, not to turn away a whole class of cars. In 2017 ICBC introduced a modified version: such vehicles could still be insured but faced higher premiums from 8 January 2017, and owners may need to apply for own damage coverage covering collision, comprehensive and specified perils.
In 2019 ICBC overhauled its liability rate structure, shifting to a private-sector style in which higher-risk drivers pay higher premiums. David Eby, the attorney general at that point, criticised the high rates, argued for cheaper cover for young drivers, and accepted that rates are still subsidised.
The bigger move came in February 2020, when the provincial government announced that ICBC would stop relying on lawsuits and adopt no-fault. Crash victims can no longer sue for damages, with exceptions where there are court convictions for offences such as negligence, street racing or impaired driving, and where faulty manufacturing, botched repairs or the over-serving of alcohol by a business is involved. Instead ICBC pays benefits, medical treatment and compensation straight to claimants, at amounts the province fixes by type of injury. It was projected to save $2.9 billion in 2022 in legal fees plus pain-and-suffering and injury claims. Of that sum, $1.2 billion was to be redirected towards treatment benefits and faster claim handling, and 1.7 billion towards the 20% rate cut.
In January 2021 the regulator, the British Columbia Utilities Commission (BCUC), approved a 15 per cent cut to basic rates. ICBC said that once Enhanced Care coverage began in May 2021, drivers would on average save 20 per cent across basic and optional insurance combined.
Money flowed back to drivers. In February 2021 the government announced a one-time cheque averaging $190, crediting an improved financial outlook that was partly the result of fewer crashes and claims during the pandemic. A second rebate in July 2021 averaged $120 per policy holder. In March 2022 ICBC said it would pay a one-time rebate of $110 to offset dearer petrol after the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. The government said the money would come from net income of $1.9 billion in the fiscal year that closed on 31 March 2022, with the rest going into capital reserves.
In December 2022 the NDP government said it had asked the BC Utilities Commission to freeze basic rates for two years, which would mean five years with no basic increase.
How does ICBC set premiums?
Like other insurers, ICBC prices according to a client's claims history, type of vehicle, location and years of driving experience. Each driver is given a "driver factor" number for every type of insurance, and that number sets the discount or surcharge they pay. A lower driver factor means a lower premium and a lower risk.
On paper, the BCUC reviews and sets basic rates. In practice the provincial Cabinet steers the outcome, because it can set target financial results, for instance capital reserves and profits, and can send Special Directives to the BCUC.
Revenue goes mostly to insurance benefits and operating costs. What remains supports its mandate to promote safe driving, through the "RoadSense" campaign, and other loss prevention work. A board of directors appointed under the Insurance Corporation Act governs the corporation, alongside the chief executive and management, and must follow the Motor Vehicle Act, other applicable laws and directions given by the provincial Cabinet Committee.
Proof of insurance used to be shown partly by a decal on the licence plate. From 1 May 2022 decals were discontinued and are no longer issued, as part of a move to online renewals.
Why is Saskatchewan's SGI the oldest public insurer?
Saskatchewan Government Insurance was created in 1945 by Tommy Douglas's CCF government, the longest-running public car insurer in the country. Saskatchewan is also the only province that lets motorists choose between no-fault and tort systems. Most people do not realise they have a choice, and by default every resident is enrolled in the no-fault scheme unless they ask to switch to tort.
A driver from outside the province who is partly or wholly to blame for a Saskatchewan crash can be pursued by the injured Saskatchewan resident for non-economic damages, whatever no-fault cover they hold at home. Minor injury benefits carry no cap, and SGI does not require claimants to attend an eventual medical assessment, which is common elsewhere.
What about Manitoba and Quebec?
Manitoba Public Insurance arrived in 1971 under Edward Schreyer's NDP government, having been central to his 1969 election campaign. It is a non-profit Crown corporation running a pure no-fault model.
In 1978 the Parti Quebecois government of Rene Levesque created the Regie de l'assurance automobile du Quebec, which became the Societe de l'assurance automobile du Quebec in 1990. Quebec's public scheme covers personal injuries only, and property damage is left to private insurers.
Which provinces considered public car insurance and said no?
Several have toyed with it. Ontario tried. The New Democrats won the 1990 election promising public auto insurance, and Premier Bob Rae gave the job of delivering it to Peter Kormos, among its loudest advocates. The early 1990s recession changed the mood: business and labour both worried about job losses and lost revenue, and the government abandoned the idea in 1991, one factor in its defeat in 1995.
New Brunswick considered public cover after private rates nearly doubled between 2003 and 2005, but the provincial government rejected it. Nova Scotia debated it in its 2003 election and the opposition NDP kept it in the 2006 platform, but it was absent in 2009 and the party's majority government never introduced a scheme. Newfoundland and Labrador's Progressive Conservative government under Danny Williams weighed it in 2004 as a last resort, after private firms threatened to withdraw in response to legislation that rolled back premiums.
Does Australia have public car insurance?
Australia uses compulsory third-party insurance (CTP) in every state, paid as part of vehicle registration. It protects the owner and anyone driving the vehicle against claims for death or injury caused by their fault, and depending on the scheme it can pay for bodily injuries, sensible medical treatment, lost income and care services, and sometimes compensation for pain and suffering.
Three states and one territory have no private CTP scheme. Victoria's Transport Accident Commission provides it, funded by a levy within registration known as the TAC charge. Tasmania has the Motor Accidents Insurance Board, Western Australia the Insurance Commission of Western Australia, and the Northern Territory's scheme runs through the Territory Insurance Office. South Australia's Motor Accident Commission provided cover until July 2016, but private companies now do.
What does this mean for someone buying car insurance?
For a driver in British Columbia, basic cover is not a shopping decision: ICBC's Autoplan is required and sold through independent brokers, and competition only arrives for optional cover. In Saskatchewan the choice is between no-fault and tort, with no-fault the default. In Manitoba and Quebec the model is no-fault, and Quebec's public scheme stops at personal injury. A buyer comparing ICBC car insurance with private insurance elsewhere is therefore comparing different rules as well as different prices.
ICBC keeps its profits and has dropped plate decals
Since the NDP passed its legislation after the 2017 election, ICBC's profits remain with the company. Licence-plate decals have been discontinued since 1 May 2022 as renewals moved online, and the corporation still holds the monopoly on basic insurance while competing with private insurers only for optional cover.



