From 2,700-year-old tolls to transponders, plate cameras and satellite units: how electronic toll collection identifies and bills a car without stopping it.
Electronic toll collection charges a car without stopping it: a roadside reader triggers a transponder, which sends an identifying number that is billed to the driver's account, or cameras read the number plate. Tolls themselves are at least 2,700 years old, and Melbourne's CityLink brought free-flow tolling to Australia in 1999.
In some cases the people who staff a toll booth cost up to about a third of everything the road collects. That is one reason toll operators spent decades trying to remove them. The result is that a car can now pass a toll point at highway speed and be billed afterwards, with no coin, no ticket and no brake light.
Tolls have funded roads for about 2,700 years. Today electronic toll collection identifies and bills a car at speed, and the Australian e-tag, the American E-ZPass and their equivalents elsewhere work on the same principle.
What a toll road is and why roads charge
A toll road, also called a tollway, or in the United States a turnpike or pike, is a public or private road that charges a fee for passage. The aim is usually to recoup the cost of building and maintaining it. The fee typically varies with vehicle type, weight or number of axles, and freight trucks are often charged more than cars. Bridges and tunnels are tolled for the same reason, to repay what they cost to build.
Collection happens at plazas, booths, houses, stations, bars, barriers or gates. Some points are automatic, where you feed money to a machine that opens the gate once the right amount is paid. Many now use electronic toll collection (ETC), which talks to a transponder in the car or reads the number plate and debits an account.
The criticisms are old and consistent. Stopping to pay takes time. Paying the people who take the money can eat up to about a third of revenue in some cases. And some drivers object to paying twice for the same road, once through fuel taxes and again at the toll. Automated systems are meant to ease the first two. Where the money goes can also be disputed: some tolls are set aside for future upkeep, while others go into a local government's general fund, which central government legislation sometimes limits or forbids.
At the toll point, the car announces itself and the bill follows.
A short history of the toll road
Travellers on the Susa to Babylon highway paid tolls under Ashurbanipal in the seventh century BC, so toll roads have existed for at least 2,700 years. Aristotle and Pliny refer to tolls in Arabia and elsewhere in Asia, the Arthashastra mentions them in India before the fourth century BC, and Germanic tribes charged travellers who crossed mountain passes. Roman roads, by contrast, were generally untolled and publicly funded.
In medieval Europe most roads were not freely open, and tolls were one of many feudal fees. Some major routes, such as the Via Regia and the Via Imperii, gave travellers protection in return for a royal toll. In 14th-century England some of the busiest roads were repaired with money raised from tolls under pavage grants. High tolls could do harm, though. Widespread tolling sometimes restricted traffic so much that it interfered with trade and with the cheap transport needed to relieve local famines or shortages. In seventeenth-century Dahomey, in West Africa, toll booths along newly built roads collected yearly taxes based on the goods carried and the traveller's occupation.
Britain's answer was the turnpike trust. Trusts were set up from 1663 by individual acts of Parliament, with powers to charge tolls and so repay loans for building and maintaining the main roads. At their peak in the 1830s, over 1,000 trusts looked after around 48,000 km (30,000 miles) of road in England and Wales and took tolls at almost 8,000 gates. The tolls were paid by road users rather than general taxation. The trusts were abolished gradually from the 1870s. Thomas Telford's Holyhead road, built in the early 19th century with many toll booths, is now mostly the A5.
The twentieth century produced the motorway. Italy built the first in the world reserved for fast traffic and motor vehicles only. The Autostrada dei Laghi, between Milan and the lakes of Como and Maggiore, was devised by civil engineer Piero Puricelli, who received the first authorisation in 1921 and finished one lane in each direction between 1924 and 1926. He covered the cost with a toll. Greece followed in 1927, and France, Spain and Portugal built motorways in the 1950s and 1960s largely through concessions, which let them develop quickly without large state debts.
In the United States many states built their first freeways by issuing bonds backed by toll revenue. The Pennsylvania Turnpike, opened in 1940, was the first major fully grade-separated toll road, followed by the Maine Turnpike in 1947. The New Jersey Turnpike came in 1951, the Garden State Parkway a year later, the New York State Thruway in 1954 and the Indiana Toll Road in 1958. The Interstate Highway System slowed things down, since federal money paid for most new freeways and regulations required them to be toll-free. Older toll roads were kept under a grandfather clause. Some, like the Connecticut Turnpike, dropped their tolls once the bonds were paid off, while many states kept charging as a steady source of revenue. When the Interstates neared completion in the 1980s, states started building toll roads again, beginning with Houston's outer beltway in 1983.
How do electronic tolls work?
A vehicle using the system carries an automatic radio transponder. As it passes a roadside reader, a radio signal wakes the transponder, which sends back an identifying number. That number records the vehicle's use of the road, and the toll is then charged by an electronic payment system. The driver never stops.
Users normally register beforehand and put money into a prepaid account that shrinks each time they pass a toll point. Modern transponders are generally mounted under the windshield, with readers in overhead gantries. Enforcement combines a camera that photographs the car with a radio-frequency computer that looks for a valid transponder. A notice and fine go to cars that pass through without an active account or payment.
Drivers without a transponder are either excluded from the lane or pay by plate. A camera uses automatic number-plate recognition to identify the car, and a bill may be mailed to the address registered for the plate, or the driver may have a set time to pay online or by phone. This is known as video tolling.
The idea is older than the technology. In 1959 the Nobel economist William Vickrey proposed that each car in the Washington area carry a transponder whose signal would be picked up at intersections and relayed to a central computer, which would work out the charge by location and time of day. Prototypes were tested in the 1960s and 1970s with transponders on the underside of vehicles and readers beneath the road surface, but the plans were scrapped.
| Year | Place | Milestone |
|---|---|---|
| 1975 | Singapore | Area Licensing Scheme, the first electronic road toll system, tested in 1974 and refined in 1998 as Electronic Road Pricing |
| 1986 | Bergen, Norway | First ETC, operating alongside traditional booths |
| 1989 | Italy | Full ETC at national scale on motorways |
| 1991 | Trondheim, Norway | World's first completely unaided full-speed electronic tolling |
| 1995 | Portugal | Via Verde, one universal system for all tolls in the country |
| 1999 | Melbourne, Australia | CityLink, the first free-flow tolling in the country |
| 2001 | Japan | ETC on all controlled-access expressways |
| 2004-2005 | Santiago, Chile | First 100% full-speed electronic tolling across a city core |
| 2007 | Dubai | Salik road toll collection |
| 2016 | Pakistan | RFID-based M-TAG across the motorway network |
Free-flow tolling and cashless toll roads
Open road tolling takes the booths away. Electronic plate readers mounted beside or over the road read transponders as vehicles pass at highway speed, so there is no bottleneck. Electronic lanes on some urban roads still carry legal limits of 8 km/h (5 mph) or 35 km/h (20 mph), but elsewhere, including the Garden State Parkway and sites in California, Florida, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Texas, cars cross at full speed. Illinois has 274 miles of barrier-free roads where I-PASS or E-ZPass users keep moving at highway speeds while cash payers pull off to booths. Over 80% of the state's 1.4 million daily drivers use an I-PASS.
The first American toll roads built with no booths at all were Maryland Route 200 and North Carolina's Triangle Expressway, with drivers charged by transponder or by optical plate recognition and billed by mail. The Massachusetts Turnpike went all-electronic in 2016. The Pennsylvania Turnpike, America's oldest toll freeway, did so in 2020, as did the Illinois Tollway, both moving faster because of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Fully free-flow systems still face obstacles. Not everyone has a transponder, so manual lanes form lines and traffic sorts itself out untidily. Evaders are hard to pursue. Some barrier systems must confine vehicles in lanes, with a risk of high-speed collisions, and retrofitting an existing plaza costs money. Long lines can build even in electronic lanes. Yet the saving is real. Even when queues are equally long, electronic tolls save time for registered cars because there is no stop at a window. Higher throughput means fewer lanes and lower construction costs, and because plazas are wider than the road, doing without them lets toll roads fit into tight corridors.
Satellite tolling goes a step further. Vehicles carry On Board Units with Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) receivers that work out the distance travelled on the tolled network, so no roadside readers are needed. Since 2005, nationwide GNSS road pricing has been deployed in several European countries. Russia's Western High-Speed Diameter in St Petersburg uses a different approach, called Flow+, in which transponders are read by receivers at entrance and exit ramps to calculate the distance driven.
E-tag toll accounts in Australia and tag schemes elsewhere
In Australia the first free-flow tolling was built in Melbourne in 1999, with CityLink. Toll roads have since appeared in most cities, and Sydney has the most, with WestConnex and NorthConnex the latest projects. Transurban operates most of them. Several organisations issue e-TAG devices that work on toll roads, including Transport for NSW's E-Toll and Transurban's Linkt, and the toll is debited to the customer's account with the tag provider. Operators in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane, among them the Sydney Harbour Tunnel, Westlink M7, CityLink, Eastlink and the Gateway Motorway, encourage tag use and add a vehicle matching fee for vehicles without one.
Other countries follow the same pattern. The US E-ZPass tag works across fifteen states, from Illinois to Maine. France uses Liber-T for light vehicles and TIS-PL for heavy goods vehicles on all its toll roads. Brazil's Sem Parar/Via-Facil system covers more than 1,000 lanes in six states and more than 100 parking lots. Pakistan has used its M-TAG on the motorway network since 2016, with a prepaid account.
Italy's Telepass, from Autostrada per l'Italia, was a leader in interoperability, linking 24 different motorway operators so that users pay only at the end of a journey. Its co-designer Mario Alvisi is considered the father of ETC in motorways, and the system became a European standard in 1996. Portugal's Via Verde can also pay at car parks and petrol stations. Japan's ETC went onto all expressways in 2001, and by 2019, 92% of drivers there were using it. Norway runs 25 toll roads with electronic fee collection, a technology it calls AutoPASS. From 2015 the Norwegian government required commercial trucks above 3.5 tons to carry a transponder and a valid subscription, because before then two-thirds of foreign trucks had failed to pay.
Italy's system is unusual in its charging methods. The toll applies to nearly all motorways not run by the state company ANAS, either as a closed system, in which the toll depends on kilometres travelled, or as an open system with a flat rate. Because there are so many operators, the toll is asked only when you leave the motorway, not when the operator changes.
The European Union has tried to bring order. Its electronic fee collection directive says systems deployed after 1 January 2007 must support at least one of three technologies: satellite positioning, GSM-GPRS mobile communications or 5.8 GHz microwave. A regulation on the European Electronic Toll Service was to be implemented by all member states from 19 October 2021. Ireland requires all toll roads to support the eToll tag standard. In the United States, the MAP-21 law of 2012 set a deadline of 1 October 2016 for an interoperability agreement.
From toll booths to congestion pricing
ETC is most disruptive in cities. Because tolls can be charged without slowing vehicles, private companies could be given concessions to build and run urban freeways, and congestion pricing became practical. Santiago pioneered the first fully free-flowing system across a city core, and Dubai followed with Salik in 2007. London introduced its congestion charge in 2003, effectively making roads in the centre of the city tolled. In the US, tolled express lanes turned free highways into revenue earners by letting drivers pay to bypass traffic jams.
Because it is easy to vary the amount, ETC also supports pricing for high-occupancy lanes, lanes that bypass congestion and city-wide charges.
Where this goes next
Japan's ETC 2.0 is designed to send and receive large amounts of information in both directions between road and vehicle, including route information, where the older system only handled toll collection. It supports congestion avoidance and safe driving support, and about 2.61 million vehicles in Japan were equipped with compliant devices by March 2018. In Europe, satellite tolling needs no roadside infrastructure, and the European Electronic Toll Service regulation was due to be in place in every member state from 19 October 2021. In the United States, new toll roads rose significantly in the first two decades of the century, spurred by electronic collection and express lane tolls.





