Why Diesel Costs More Than Petrol in Some Places and Less in Others
Features

Why Diesel Is Dearer Than Petrol in Britain but Taxed 28% Lower in Germany

Photo: Meena Kadri, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Source · Licence

Equal energy per kilogram, a denser litre, a sulfur-stripping refinery step and a patchwork of taxes and subsidies decide which fuel is cheaper at the pump.

FeaturesBy 9 min read
The short answer

Diesel and petrol carry nearly the same energy per kilogram, but diesel is denser and needs sulfur removal. Its pump price relative to petrol depends largely on national tax and subsidy policy: higher in parts of the US, the UK and Australia, while Germany taxes diesel about 28% lower.

Diesel and petrol hold almost exactly the same energy per kilogram, 43.1 megajoules against 43.2, yet the price gap between them runs in opposite directions depending on which country's forecourt you pull into. In Germany the fuel tax on diesel is about 28% lower than on petrol. Diesel can cost more in the United Kingdom, in Australia and in many parts of America.

The difference comes from refining, from a fuel that is denser than it looks, and from national tax and subsidy decisions that have nothing to do with chemistry. A pump price is assembled from crude oil, refining, distribution and tax, and each piece varies from one country to the next.

What is diesel fuel?

Diesel fuel is any liquid fuel designed for a diesel engine, in which the inlet air is compressed and the fuel is then injected, igniting without a spark. That makes good compression-ignition behaviour the key requirement; the measure of it is the cetane number, and European road diesel must reach a minimum of 51. The most common diesel is a specific distillate of petroleum fuel oil.

Fuels that do not come from crude, among them biodiesel and the biomass-to-liquid and gas-to-liquid kinds, are increasingly in development and use. Refineries make diesel in large volumes, and many countries standardise it: in the European Union the standard is EN 590. By 2016, nearly all petroleum diesel sold in Britain, continental Europe and North America was of the ultra-low-sulfur type.

The name changes with the country. In Britain road diesel is called diesel or sometimes white diesel, to separate it from the dyed, reduced-tax agricultural product known as red diesel, and its official term is DERV, for diesel-engine road vehicle. Australia also uses the word distillate, while Indonesia and most of the Middle East call it Solar, a trademark of the national oil company Pertamina.

Gasoline pump price, 202153.6%Crude oil16.4%Taxes15.6%Distributionand marketing14.4%RefiningCrude oil is the main factor
In 2021 crude oil made up just over half of the US gasoline pump price, with taxes, distribution and marketing, and refining sharing the rest.
Same energy per kilogram, opposite price gaps: national pricing policy does the rest.

How is diesel made, and why is it not the same as petrol?

Petroleum diesel is produced by distilling crude oil between 200 and 350 degrees Celsius (392 and 662 degrees Fahrenheit) at atmospheric pressure. The resulting mixture of molecules typically contains chains of 9 to 25 carbon atoms, and it then goes through hydrodesulfurization to strip out sulfur.

Diesel straight from the still is rarely enough in volume or quality, so refiners top it up. Heavier fractions are cracked, and the product needs hydrogenation to remove olefins. Hydrocracking supplies another stream, and kerosene is added to adjust viscosity. Natural gas can also be converted to synthesis gas and then, by the Fischer-Tropsch process, to a synthetic diesel low in sulfur and aromatics that is often blended into the petroleum product.

Biodiesel comes from vegetable oil or animal fat, mostly reacted with methanol to make fatty acid methyl esters. Rapeseed is the usual oil in Europe and soybean in the US. It can be used neat as B100 where an engine maker approves, but it is more often blended, with the number after the B showing the percentage. Small doses of additives complete the fuel: ethylene-vinyl acetate at 50 to 500 parts per million stops waxes crystallising and blocking filters in the cold.

Refining diesel is generally simpler than refining petrol. The extra step is sulfur removal, which can push the cost up. Sweden sells a class 1 environmental diesel, MK-1, with an aromatics limit of 5%, and it costs slightly more to make than ordinary ultra-low-sulfur diesel.

Is a litre of diesel the same as a litre of petrol?

Not quite. Diesel is denser, so a litre contains more fuel than a litre of petrol. The density of EN 590 diesel is defined as 0.820 to 0.845 kilograms per litre, about 9.0 to 13.9% more than the 0.720 to 0.775 of EN 228 petrol. That gives diesel a higher energy density by volume, which matters when comparing prices per litre.

PropertyDiesel (EN 590)Petrol (EN 228)
Net heating value43.1 MJ/kg43.2 MJ/kg
Density at 15 degrees C0.820 to 0.845 kg/L0.720 to 0.775 kg/L
CO2 emitted73.25 g/MJ73.38 g/MJ

What goes into a pump price?

A fuel price is built from the cost of crude, processing and delivery, then adjusted for local demand, the currency, tax or subsidy and how much supply is nearby. Since fuels are traded worldwide, trade prices are similar from place to place. What the motorist pays mostly follows national policy: nearly every country taxes petrol, a few such as Venezuela subsidise it, and no country's taxes cover all the pollution and CO2 costs of using it.

The American Energy Information Administration (EIA) publishes a breakdown for gasoline. From 2012 through 2021, with an average price of $2.80 a gallon, crude oil made up 54.8%, taxes 17%, distribution and marketing 14.3% and refining 14%. In 2021 the shares were 53.6% for crude, 16.4% for taxes, 15.6% for distribution and marketing, and 14.4% for refining. Crude oil is the main factor behind both gasoline and diesel prices.

Crude can move hard. Between 2004 and 2008, rising global demand lifted oil from $35 to $140 a barrel, and pump prices followed. OPEC production decisions and speculation play a part. Retail margins sit inside the distribution and marketing slice; forecourt retailers typically take a gross margin of 30 to 35 cents a gallon, and these margins tend to shrink when oil surges and widen when it falls. Weather events, conflict and laws requiring cleaner-burning fuels can raise prices, and demand usually rises in summer.

The swings

The recent American record shows how far the total can move. The national average gasoline price fell to $1.73 a gallon in early 2020, rose to $3.01 in 2021 and passed $5 by June 2022, with some areas reporting $6. March 2026 saw it rise past $4 for the first time since 2022, mainly because of disruptions to the global oil supply.

Why does diesel sometimes cost more than petrol?

Where diesel is dearer, the reasons given are practical. Price comparisons per gallon or litre often show diesel above petrol across the UK and Australia and in many American regions. Explanations include some Gulf of Mexico refineries closing, refining capacity being diverted to petrol, and the move to ultra-low-sulfur diesel, which has caused infrastructure complications. The additional refining needed to remove sulfur adds a sometimes higher cost.

Why does diesel sometimes cost less?

Tax and subsidy are the usual reasons. In Germany the diesel fuel tax is about 28% lower than the petrol tax. In India, diesel is taxed less than petrol, because the majority of transport for grain and other essentials across the country runs on diesel. Trinidad and Tobago, which subsidises its fuels, sells diesel at US$0.24 a litre against US$0.43 for Ron 91 petrol and US$0.91 for Ron 95, which puts its diesel among the world's cheapest.

Indonesia shows diesel sitting below petrol under subsidy too. In May 2008, with oil above US$145 a barrel, Indonesia raised petrol to 6,000 rupiah a litre and diesel to 5,500, moves that caused widespread protests. In November 2014 it raised both by 2,000 rupiah, to 8,500 and 7,500 respectively, again amid protest and inflation.

Subsidy cuts and the street

Removing a subsidy tends to bring people out. Bolivia ended price fixes on petrol and diesel in December 2010, raising petrol by as much as 83%, then cancelled planned future hikes after widespread strikes. Nigeria tried to end its petrol subsidy in January 2012, and an eight-day general strike and riots forced a retreat to a lower price; the government cut the subsidy sharply after 2023 and eliminated it a year later, and President Tinubu said in November 2024 that this was saving US$7.5 billion a year. Venezuela, which long had the world's cheapest petrol, raised fuel prices by 6000% on 19 February 2016, the first rise in 20 years. Mexico ended its oil industry subsidies in 2017, with higher prices and protests across the country. Before that, its subsidised sales had caused frequent shortages at border filling stations, hurting truck and bus drivers who run on diesel.

Malaysia shows the managed approach. It abolished fuel subsidies in 2014 and moved to a managed float. Diesel stayed at RM2.15 a litre from 12 February 2021 until 10 June 2024, when the prime minister placed West Malaysian diesel on a managed float, with Sarawak and Sabah planned to follow. In September 2025 the government revived petrol support through a programme called BUDI95, reached the general public on 30 September. In the 2026 Strait of Hormuz crisis, the government's bill for keeping the subsidies hit RM3.2 billion a month.

Why is red diesel cheaper?

Because it is taxed differently. Diesel is similar to heating oil, but in Europe, the United States and Canada diesel carries the fuel tax and heating oil does not, so heating oil is marked with dyes and trace chemicals to catch fraud. Untaxed off-road diesel, dyed red, is available in some countries for farm use, tractors and other noncommercial vehicles that stay off public roads. Its sulfur level may exceed road limits in places such as the US, and using it for a taxed purpose such as driving can be fined, for example US$10,000 in the US.

Belgium, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom call the dyed fuel red diesel, or gas oil. They use it in farm vehicles, home heating tanks, refrigeration units on vans and trucks that carry perishables, and marine craft. Marked gas oil is green in Ireland and Norway. American biodiesel tax differs from state to state: Texas charges none on the biodiesel itself and discounts blends in proportion, which leaves B20 taxed 20% below pure petrodiesel.

Who sets pump prices in Europe and Britain?

Fuel taxes in most of Europe exceed American ones, but Russia and some neighbours levy far less and see prices close to the US level. In Britain the lead on petrol prices is taken by supermarkets that run forecourts, and each tends to match the others: Asda, Tesco, Sainsbury's and Morrisons.

Where did diesel fuel come from?

Rudolf Diesel invented his compression-ignition engine around 1892 and at first claimed it would run on any fuel in any state of matter, though the early prototypes ran only on liquids. He tested crude oil from Pechelbronn but found it too thick, so he moved to petrol and kerosene. Lamp oils, ligroin, coal-tar creosote, paraffin oil and fuel oil all worked in time. In Scotland and France, shale oil powered the first 1898 production engines because the alternatives were too expensive. An engine shown at the 1900 Paris Exposition ran on peanut oil with no modification. A coal-dust prototype tested in December 1899 suffered piston ring failure after a few minutes.

Early diesels ran on cheap fuel oils: distilled from petroleum in the US, coal-tar creosote oil in Europe. Some burned blends of petrol, kerosene, rapeseed oil or lubricating oil, cheaper because these were untaxed at the time. Motor-vehicle engines such as the Mercedes-Benz OM 138 of the 1930s needed better fuel, and the first modern standards, DIN 51601, VTL 9140-001 and NATO F 54, came after the Second World War. In 1993 the European standard EN 590 replaced DIN 51601 and is still the European Union standard.

At sea, diesel propulsion gained ground by the late 1970s because of fuel costs raised by the 1970s energy crisis, and cheap heavy fuel oils, often called Bunker C, are still burned rather than road diesel.

What is still changing in diesel pricing?

Several threads run forward from here. Non-petroleum diesels, biodiesel, biomass to liquid and gas to liquid, keep gaining ground in development and use. Malaysia has a plan to extend its managed float for diesel to Sarawak and Sabah in future. Nigeria's subsidy is gone, while Malaysia has revived petrol support. And in March 2026 the American average gasoline price rose above $4 a gallon for the first time since 2022 after global supply disruptions.

Frequently asked questions

Why is diesel so expensive in some countries?
Reasons given include refinery shutdowns in the Gulf of Mexico, refining capacity being diverted to petrol, the move to ultra-low-sulfur diesel and the extra refining needed to remove sulfur. Taxes and local demand also play a part.
Is diesel cheaper than petrol anywhere?
Yes. Germany taxes diesel about 28% below petrol, India taxes it less because grain and essentials travel by diesel, and Trinidad and Tobago sells diesel at US$0.24 a litre against US$0.43 for Ron 91 petrol.
Does diesel contain more energy than petrol?
Per kilogram the two are almost identical, 43.1 and 43.2 MJ/kg. Diesel is about 9.0 to 13.9% denser, so a litre offers more energy, which matters when comparing prices per litre.
What is red diesel?
It is untaxed or reduced-tax diesel dyed red for farm and other off-road use. Using it for a taxed purpose such as driving can be fined, for example US$10,000 in the US. In Ireland and Norway marked gas oil is dyed green.
What makes up the price of a litre of fuel?
For US gasoline in 2021, crude oil was 53.6%, taxes 16.4%, distribution and marketing 15.6% and refining 14.4%. Crude oil is the main factor for both gasoline and diesel prices.

Sources

  1. Diesel fuel - Wikipedia
  2. Gasoline and diesel usage and pricing - Wikipedia
Next story / Profiles

Toyota Corolla E140: The Tenth-Generation Corolla Around the World