Features

Brake Fade Is Heat Overload in Pads, Fluid or Drums, and You Can Feel Which

Firm pedal or spongy pedal, drums or discs: why brakes lose their bite when hot, how to prevent it, and what a car does to brake while turning.

FeaturesBy 10 min read
The short answer

Heat builds up in the pads, shoes or fluid and the brakes stop the car less well: the pedal either stays firm with weak braking, or goes spongy. Cornering brake control, which BMW introduced in 1992, manages the force on each brake while the car is turning.

Two kinds of brake fade feel almost opposite. In one, the pedal stays firm under your foot and the car simply refuses to slow. In the other, the pedal turns soft and spongy. Both are the same underlying problem, heat, arriving by different routes, and the difference tells you which part of the system has given up.

What is brake fade?

Brake fade is a loss of stopping power after repeated or sustained use of the brakes, especially under high load or at high speed. It is not a quirk of one type of vehicle. Any machine with friction brakes can suffer it, from cars and trucks to motorcycles, aeroplanes and bicycles, and it shows up in both drum and disc systems.

The trigger is heat. Friction turns a moving vehicle's energy into heat in the braking surfaces, and if more arrives than the brakes can shed, parts of the system start to change and react in ways that cost grip. Most cases occur during high performance driving or on a long, steep descent.

Drum brakes are more prone to it because of how they are laid out, whereas disc brakes shed heat from the rotor and pads far more easily. That is a big reason discs became the standard choice for the front brakes of most vehicles.

Three kinds of brake fade: friction fade, fluid fade and mechanical fadeHeatFriction fadePad or shoe liningReaches its kneepointPedal stays firmFluid fadeHydraulic fluidFluid boils and releases gasPedal turns spongyMechanical fadeDrum and shoesDrum expands, gap growsEats into pedal travel
Heat causes three kinds of brake fade: the lining reaches its kneepoint and the pedal stays firm, the fluid boils and the pedal turns spongy, or the drum expands.
Fade is caused by heat, and the pedal tells you which part of the system has given up.

What causes brake fade?

Three different mechanisms are at work, and they hit different parts of the car.

Friction fade

Every pad and shoe lining has a temperature-friction curve, and at a point on it known as the kneepoint, friction drops away and gas collects between disc and pad. The linings themselves are made by curing under pressure, heating the friction material to 232 degrees Celsius (450 degrees Fahrenheit) so that phenolic resin polymers cross-link. Those resins are thermosets, not thermoplastics, so they do not melt as they overheat. The pedal in this form of fade stays firm, but the stopping ability has gone.

Fluid fade

The second route runs through the hydraulics. If the brake fluid boils, it releases gases, and gas can be compressed in a way that liquid cannot. The pedal feels spongy. Water makes it worse: most brake fluids absorb it to some degree, which is why replacing the fluid is standard maintenance. Fade from overheated fluid is often called pedal fade.

Mechanical fade

The third is about geometry. A drum expands as it heats, which opens up the gap between brake shoe and drum and eats into the pedal travel. Self-adjusting brakes largely remedied this in the 1950s, but poor adjustment through wear remains an issue for trucks with drum air brakes. A Canadian roadside check of heavy trucks picked at random found more than 10 per cent of those with self-adjusting brakes had at least one brake needing adjustment, either because the adjuster had failed or because wear had outrun it.

Newer brake chambers are one response. They lengthen the stroke from roughly 65 mm to 75 mm (2.6 in to 3.0 in). Around 30 mm (1.2 in) goes just on bringing the pads up to the drum, so the additional 10 mm (0.4 in) is a gain of more than 25 per cent in usable stroke.

Brake fade symptoms: firm pedal, spongy pedal and swerving

TypeWhere it startsWhat is happening
Friction fadePad or shoe liningLining reaches its kneepoint; gas builds between disc and pad
Fluid fadeHydraulic fluidFluid boils and releases compressible gas
Mechanical fadeDrum and shoesDrum expands; shoe clearance grows

A further symptom appears when fade is uneven: the vehicle may swerve. Once cooled, brakes that have faded usually work as they did before and look unchanged. But if they have been very hot for a long time, the friction surfaces can glaze, turning smooth and shiny and slowing the vehicle less effectively. Glazing can be removed by rubbing the linings gently with emery paper, or by driving carefully, braking lightly, over several miles.

Why drum brakes fade harder

Many drum designs, along with band brakes, are self-assisting. When you apply them, part of the braking force is fed back into the mechanism and applies the brake harder, a trick known as positive feedback or self-servo. It cuts the effort you need at the pedal, but it magnifies fade, because a loss of friction material reduces the force pressing the lining on. A conventional disc has no self-assist. Lose some pad thickness and the pad force stays put.

How much the self-assist amplifies things depends on the design. In the Ausco Lambert and Murphy designs, self-assist rises roughly in step with friction, so total braking drops roughly as the square of the friction loss. Many common drum and band brakes are worse: their self-assist is exponential, governed by the friction coefficient and the angle at which shoes and drum engage. A small change in friction therefore causes a large change in assist. A slight rise can lock a wheel under a light touch, and that is why drum brakes can grab on a damp morning and skid to a stop even after the pedal is released. A slight fall, conversely, can mean severe fade.

When fade cascades on heavy vehicles

A typical five-axle truck and trailer combination has 10 brakes. If one fades, its share of the work moves to the other nine, which then run harder and hotter and fade in their turn. Heavy vehicles often fit disproportionately weak brakes on the steered wheels to avoid swerving when fade is uneven, which lengthens stopping distances and loads the other wheels still more. Discs, which fade less, let steered wheels do more of the braking without brake steer.

Air drag is small next to the weight of a heavy truck, so the brakes absorb proportionally more energy than on a car or motorcycle. Heavy vehicles therefore lean on engine compression braking and slow down so the energy is shed over a longer stretch. Many European heavy vehicles use discs. Many American and third-world trucks use drums because they cost less to buy, and big trucks stay with drums for reasons of cost and packaging, since a drum fits easily into spaces where a disc of equal capacity would not.

The gap may be smaller than assumed. Recent American studies tested drum and disc stopping distances under FMVSS-121 and found that when the newer friction materials usually fitted to discs are applied to drums, the two behave almost identically for stopping distance and fade. The rules for Class Eight trucks built from 2012 cut required stopping distances by about a third, and the law does not recommend either type. One technology claim goes further: fitting brake turbines inside a specially configured drum is said to cut temperatures by around half and almost eliminate fade.

On the railways, discs have been used on passenger cars for more than 60 years, paired with the Rolokron anti-lock system to avoid flat spots on wheels. On high speed trains such as the TGV an axle may carry as many as four disks. In 1988 British railway engineers developed the first modern ceramic brakes for the TGV, aiming to cut weight and the number of brakes per axle while keeping friction stable at every speed and temperature. The carbon-fibre-reinforced ceramic process is now used for road, rail and aircraft brakes.

How to prevent brake fade

The cheapest fix is technique. On a long downgrade, select a lower gear; for many trucks on steep American grades, that is required. Brake in bursts rather than continuously, because periodic application gives the brakes time to cool. Continuous light braking is particularly destructive, adding heat and wear together.

Beyond driving, performance parts attack fade from several directions.

  • Pads with a higher coefficient of friction stop harder, and pricier binding resins that melt at a higher temperature resist fade.
  • Slotted, drilled or dimpled discs are intended to reduce the gaseous boundary layer and to help dissipate heat.
  • Body modifications can direct cold air towards the brakes.
  • Thermal barriers between pad and caliper piston stop heat reaching the fluid. Some racing calipers have heat shields of titanium or ceramic, and aftermarket titanium shields are inexpensive, easy to fit and popular with racers and track day enthusiasts.
  • Cooling shims slide into the same place. Made from a composite of high thermal conductivity, they carry heat out to a heat sink in the airflow, outside the caliper.
  • On drums, drilling a pattern of holes lets rotation pump air through the shoe-to-drum gap, throws out water and lets some dust escape. It is described as an advanced job for professionals.

Not everyone agrees on drilled discs. One view holds that venting gas is the reason for holes, and it describes this as a belief carried over from drum brakes to motorcycles, bicycles and sports cars. The same view holds that discs on railway, aircraft and ordinary passenger cars carry no such vents because there is no gas to vent, and that where discs are internally ventilated, it is by radial air passages. Whichever view you take, the principle both share is that anything which removes heat from the braking surfaces helps.

What is cornering brake control?

Everything above concerns brakes that are getting too hot. Cornering brake control (CBC) is about braking while turning, when forces on the car are uneven. It is a safety function that distributes braking force between the wheels as the car goes through a bend. BMW introduced it in 1992, in the 750i, the 7 Series saloon, under the name Dynamic Stability Control. It was an addition to the company's existing ABS and Automatic Stability Control.

Regulation then spread it. The EU in 2009 and the United States in 2011 required electronic stability control, which includes CBC functions, so other makers adopted it under their own names. Mercedes-Benz markets it in ESP Dynamic Cornering Assist and Curve Dynamic Assist. Mini and Land Rover use the Cornering Brake Control name directly. Today the technology is found in electric and petrol cars, motorcycles and trucks, usually as part of electronic stability control.

How does cornering brake control work?

CBC runs on the car's electronic control unit, fed by sensors that read speed, acceleration, yaw rate and steering angle. From those it adjusts four things: brake pressure, brake steer torque, the target yaw rate and the distance needed to stop.

Brake pressure

Locking a wheel mid-corner is dangerous, because the wheel stops steering. CBC counters this with an adaptive brake force system that divides pressure among the brakes according to the vehicle's speed and its position in the curve. The result is smoother steering and braking and less chance of a wheel locking.

Yaw rate

Yaw is the twisting motion of a car as it turns. CBC steers the car towards a desired yaw rate. The actual yaw rate is the forward speed divided by the radius of the turn. The desired rate adds a correction: the actual rate plus a scaling factor, set for each make and model, multiplied by how quickly the driver is changing the steering angle. When the two disagree, CBC partially applies the brakes to ease the car into the desired motion. Settling the yaw rate also lets brake pressure fall readily during sudden braking and reduces the slip ratio, which helps the system read the road accurately.

Brake steer torque

Think of a shopping trolley with one sticky wheel: it pulls to one side. Uneven braking forces do something similar to a car, and brake steer torque is the measure of that pull. It depends on the force and on the distance from where it acts, and CBC works to reduce it. In modern vehicles the steering axis may be shifted sideways, towards the tyre contact point, so that the system can account directly for the force at the tyre. Lower brake steer torque keeps the car from veering outward and leaving its lane, compensating for driver error.

Stopping distance

By lowering brake pressure, yaw rate and torque together, CBC limits sideways movement. That improves stability in the turn and shortens the distance needed to stop, which matters when an emergency appears ahead.

How cornering brake control was tested

Experiments used Hardware-in-the-Loop testing to prove CBC responds in real time. Software-in-the-Loop testing placed the logic in a simulated environment that modelled tyres, suspension, mass and the driver's expected behaviour. The results clearly showed that CBC logic keeps vehicles on their intended path, and the researchers described it as an enhancement of the traditional ABS safety measure. The software may be paired with ABS, comparing the speeds of the wheels and adjusting variables such as brake steer torque.

Where this goes next

Autonomous vehicles are expected to carry CBC as well, since its precision and real-time response suit systems that must brake safely in a turn. It can already engage the brakes on its own in an emergency, but it lacks the signals to control a vehicle with no human input. Controller Area Network signals sent within the vehicle's software could feed it the data it needs, so that an autonomous car could rely on its logic.

What it means for a buyer or a driver

Most of the cure for fade is behavioural: gear down, brake in bursts, change the fluid on schedule. Performance pad and disc upgrades are aimed mainly at racers and track-day drivers. Cornering brake control, meanwhile, needs nothing from you. If your car has stability control, which is required by regulation in the EU and the US, it is probably already there, working beneath whatever name the manufacturer has chosen.

Frequently asked questions

Why do brakes fade?
Heat. Friction fade happens when the lining reaches its kneepoint and gas builds between disc and pad. Fluid fade comes from boiling brake fluid. Mechanical fade comes from drums expanding and increasing shoe clearance.
How do I tell what type of brake fade I have?
A firm pedal with poor stopping points to friction fade. A spongy pedal suggests the brake fluid has boiled and released compressible gas. Water in the fluid makes that worse, which is why replacing it is standard maintenance.
How can brake fade be prevented?
Use a lower gear on long descents, brake in bursts so the brakes cool, and replace brake fluid regularly. Higher-melting-point resins, ventilated or slotted discs, heat shields, cooling shims and directed cooling air can also help.
Are disc brakes immune to fade?
No. Discs resist fade better than drums because heat vents from the rotor and pads more easily, but any friction brake can fade under sustained heavy use, and fluid can still boil.
What does cornering brake control do?
A stability function that distributes braking force while a car turns. It uses sensors for speed, yaw rate and steering angle to adjust brake pressure and brake steer torque. BMW introduced it in 1992 on the 750i.

Sources

  1. Brake fade - Wikipedia
  2. Cornering brake control - Wikipedia
Next story / Features

Solid-state batteries are still not in showrooms, and the dates keep moving