A petrol engine can convert at most 73.0 per cent of the heat in its fuel, and real ones manage far less. Here is where the rest goes and how it is measured.
Thermal efficiency is useful work divided by the heat in the fuel. In petrol, 60 to 80 per cent of the energy leaves as heat, split between exhaust and coolant, so a road car turns only a fifth to two-fifths into motion. Brake-specific fuel consumption, fuel burned per unit of power, exposes an engine's sweet spot.
Burn petrol at 816 degrees Celsius in a perfect, frictionless engine on a 21 degree day, and the laws of physics say you can turn at most 73.0 per cent of the fuel's heat into motion. No engine, however clever, can do better. Real ones fall far short of even that ceiling: a typical petrol car engine manages around 25 per cent, and the rest of the energy leaves as heat.
What is engine thermal efficiency?
Thermal efficiency is the ratio of useful work coming out of a heat engine to the heat going in. A tidy way to remember it is benefit divided by cost, since the input heat normally costs real money. The result is a pure number with no units, and it can never reach 100 per cent: the first law of thermodynamics says output cannot exceed input, and the second says that in a real process it cannot even equal it. Friction and heat loss turn the rest into other forms of energy.
For engines that burn fuel there are two flavours, indicated thermal efficiency and brake thermal efficiency. When engine efficiency is worked out, the work that counts is the power delivered at the clutch or driveshaft, so friction and other losses are already subtracted. An engine that delivers no work to the outside world has zero efficiency. The measure is only appropriate for comparing like with like, and engine efficiency is just one part of a vehicle's fuel efficiency, alongside transmission and tyre design.
Even at its best operating point, about 60 to 80 per cent of the heat released by the petrol is not turned into useful work.
How efficient is a petrol engine?
The answer depends on which figure you pick, and the numbers do not line up neatly. A typical petrol car engine operates at around 25 per cent. Elsewhere the average car engine is put at less than 35 per cent, and most road-legal cars are said to reach about 20 to 40 per cent. Modern petrol engines can top 50 per cent at their very best, though squeezing out more efficiency often costs extra wear and emissions.
Where does the rest go? Even at its best operating point, about 60 to 80 per cent of the heat energy released by the petrol is thrown away as heat instead of turning the crankshaft. Roughly half of that rejected heat leaves with the exhaust, and half passes through the cylinder walls and head into the cooling system, then out through the radiator. Friction, noise, air turbulence and the work of driving the water pump, oil pump and generator take a further share, leaving only about 20 to 40 per cent of the fuel's energy to move the car.
| Engine | Peak thermal efficiency |
|---|---|
| Typical petrol car engine | Around 25% |
| Hybrid petrol drivetrain | Close to 40% |
| Diesel trucks, buses and newer diesel cars | Around 45% |
| Formula 1 power unit | Around 45-50% |
| Largest diesel engine in the world | 51.7% |
| Large coal-fuelled power plant | About 46% |
| Combined cycle power plant | Approaching 60% |
Figures for the top of the diesel range vary. The largest diesel in the world is put at 51.7 per cent, while the low-speed MAN S80ME-C7 is credited with 54.4 per cent, the highest conversion of fuel into power by any single-cycle engine, internal or external combustion.
Why are engines inefficient?
Even the best heat engines usually fall below 50 per cent, and often far below. A large share of the world's fuel is burned in them, so perhaps as much as half of the useful energy produced worldwide is lost to engine inefficiency, although some cogeneration, combined cycle and recycling schemes now put waste heat to other uses. The inefficiency has three causes.
The Carnot limit
The first is a theoretical ceiling set by temperature. The second law of thermodynamics says that even an ideal, frictionless engine cannot convert anywhere near all of its input heat into work. Two temperatures decide how much it can convert: the temperature at which heat enters the engine, and the temperature of the surroundings into which it dumps waste heat, both measured on an absolute scale such as kelvin. The maximum efficiency is one minus the cold temperature divided by the hot.
Think of a water wheel. Its output depends on how far the water falls, from the top of the wheel to the bottom. Heat works the same way: the engine can only extract power from the drop between the hot end and the cold end. In the petrol example, fuel burning at 816 degrees Celsius (1500 degrees Fahrenheit, or 1089 K) with the surroundings at 21 degrees Celsius (70 degrees Fahrenheit, or 294 K) gives a ceiling of 73.0 per cent. No device that converts heat to mechanical energy can exceed this Carnot efficiency. The only things that can get around it are devices that turn a fuel's chemical energy straight into electrical work, such as fuel cells.
The limits of the engine cycle
The second cause is the cycle each engine uses. The ideal Carnot cycle adds all its heat at the maximum temperature and removes it at the minimum. In an internal combustion engine, the mixture in the cylinder is nowhere near peak temperature when the fuel starts to burn and reaches it only as the last of the fuel burns off, which drags down the average temperature at which heat goes in, and efficiency drops with it.
Real-world behaviour
The third cause is everything a real engine does that an ideal one does not. Moving parts produce friction. Some friction stays constant, some rises with engine speed, such as piston side forces and bearing forces, and a few forces, like the one on the cam lobes, fall at higher speed. On top of that comes the work of pumping air into and out of the cylinders. Pumping loss is minimal at low speed and rises approximately as the square of speed, until at rated power an engine uses about 20 per cent of its power output overcoming friction and pumping losses.
Throttling matters, too. At small throttle openings, a petrol engine loses efficiency to high turbulence and head loss as incoming air struggles past the nearly closed throttle. At part throttle the effective compression ratio is lower than at full throttle, because the mixture cannot fill the chamber to atmospheric pressure. One answer is variable displacement, which shuts down some cylinders in a multi-cylinder engine so the others work harder at a higher effective compression ratio. At high speed, pumping and friction losses and the shorter time available for combustion all cut efficiency, and idling is poor because no useful work is being drawn off.
How compression ratio changes efficiency
For internal combustion engines, the most important factor is the expansion ratio. The work an engine can extract is proportional to the difference between starting and ending pressure in the expansion stroke, so a higher starting pressure is a good way to get more. A typical petrol engine has a compression ratio of 10:1 on premium fuel or 9:1 on regular, with some reaching 12:1 or more. In principle the bigger the ratio, the better the efficiency, but a higher ratio needs higher octane fuel to avoid knock. Because high octane petrol costs more, four cars in five are built with lower compression so they can run on regular fuel, giving up some efficiency.
Engines that ignite fuel by compression, such as the diesel, run at ratios between 14:1 and 25:1 and do not need high octane fuel. In most petrol and diesel engines the two ratios are the same. Atkinson and Miller cycle engines gain efficiency by letting the gas expand through a bigger ratio than it was compressed by. The Atkinson cycle is the most efficient, but most petrol engine makers choose the Otto cycle because it gives more power and torque.
Diesel vs petrol efficiency
Diesel engines are usually the more efficient of the two, which is slightly surprising, because the Diesel cycle by itself is less efficient than the petrol cycle at equal compression ratios. The reason is that diesels use far higher compression, since the heat of compression ignites the slow-burning fuel, and the higher ratio more than makes up for losses in pumping air. Diesels also have no throttle in the intake, so they avoid the pump loss that hurts a petrol engine at small throttle openings.
Not every high ratio helps. Diesels running above 20:1 are indirect injection designs with a prechamber, which allows the high revs needed in cars and light trucks, but the thermal and gas flow losses of that prechamber make direct injection diesels more efficient despite their lower ratios. Modern turbo-diesels add electronically controlled common-rail fuel injection, and a variable-geometry turbocharger raises torque at low engine speeds of 1,200 to 1,800 rpm. Big diesel trucks, buses and newer diesel cars can peak around 45 per cent.
Gas turbines follow the same rule, only more steeply. They are most efficient at maximum power, and at lower rotational speed the compressed air loses pressure, so efficiency slides steadily and is very poor at low power. General Motors once built a gas-turbine bus but abandoned the idea when crude oil prices rose in the 1970s. Rover, Chrysler and Toyota built prototype turbine cars, and Chrysler made a short series for road trials. Comfort was good, but economy suffered.
What does BSFC reveal about an engine?
Brake-specific fuel consumption, or BSFC, gauges the fuel efficiency of any engine that burns fuel and drives a shaft. It is simply the rate of fuel use divided by the power produced, which is why it is also called power-specific fuel consumption. The word brake is historical; it refers to an old method of measuring torque, the Prony brake. Because BSFC is expressed per unit of power, the fuel efficiency of very different engines can be compared directly.
The calculation uses numbers that are easy to measure with an engine on a test stand under load: the fuel consumed per second, and the power, which is torque multiplied by engine speed. The usual unit is grams per kilowatt-hour. To turn that into a real efficiency, you need the energy density of the fuel, and the lower heating value is used because heat below 150 degrees Celsius (300 degrees Fahrenheit) cannot be put to use. Regular petrol is 0.0122222 kW-h per gram and diesel 0.0119531, so diesel efficiency is 1 divided by BSFC times 0.0119531.
Cycle average and sweet spot
An engine's BSFC changes with speed and load. A reciprocating engine is at its most efficient when intake air is unthrottled and it runs near peak torque. The efficiency usually quoted for an engine is a cycle average from fuel-economy testing, not its best.
The example given for a petrol engine is a cycle average of 322 g/(kW-h), which works out at an efficiency of 25 per cent. The most efficient point in a production petrol engine is about 225 g/(kW-h), equivalent to 36 per cent. On a diesel's fuel island map, a plot of BSFC against speed and torque, the sweet spot at 206 gives 40.6 per cent. Across engine classes the range is wide, from below 200 g/(kW-h) for a slow-turning, high-torque diesel to over 1,000 for a turboprop at low power.
Where this goes next
Efficiency gains are coming from several directions. Hybrid drivetrains that pair an Atkinson and Otto engine with an electric motor, including Toyota's hybrids and Mazda's Skyactiv-G, can reach effective efficiencies close to 40 per cent. Formula 1 regulations have pushed teams to develop power units peaking around 45 to 50 per cent. Variable displacement and common-rail injection are already in production, and schemes that reuse waste heat are beginning to appear.
What it means for a buyer or a driver
Quoted efficiency is an average, and your own driving moves you around the map. An engine does best unthrottled and near peak torque, and worst at idle, at small throttle openings and at high revs. Of the fuel you buy, most leaves as heat, with only about 20 to 40 per cent available to move the car. If you compare engines on BSFC, remember that a lower number is better, because it means less fuel for the same power.




