Doug DeMuro, Donut Media, Roadkill and Cleetus McFarland Built Car Audiences on Video
Features

Doug DeMuro's Cars & Bids Drew a US$37 Million Stake in 2023

Photo: Cleetus McFarland, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Source · Licence

A US$37 million auction stake, a toy line, a magazine and a race track: four routes from YouTube to something bigger.

FeaturesBy 9 min read
The short answer

Doug DeMuro built a review channel and the Cars & Bids auction site, Donut Media grew from viral videos into toys and podcasts, Roadkill ran junkyard builds for MotorTrend, and Cleetus McFarland turned a drag racing channel into a part-time NASCAR and ARCA career.

In January 2023 The Chernin Group paid US$37 million for a majority stake in a car auction website that a car reviewer had launched less than three years earlier. The reviewer was Doug DeMuro, and the website, Cars & Bids, was an offshoot of the YouTube channel he had spent years building.

Four names show how car video audiences have been built in different ways: Doug DeMuro with his review channel, Donut Media with its explainers and builds, the Roadkill web series with its junkyard projects, and Cleetus McFarland, who turned drag-strip stunts into a racing career.

Doug DeMuro and the DougScore

Doug DeMuro (Douglas Andrew DeMuro, born 22 May 1988) works as a YouTuber, author, columnist and businessman. His car review channel passed five million subscribers by April 2026. He grew up in Denver and studied economics at Emory University in Atlanta. As early as 2009, Automobile magazine had profiled his hobby of car spotting.

After college he took a job at Porsche's North American base in Atlanta allocating vehicles, and wrote for Autotrader.com on the side. In 2013 he quit to write about cars full time, contributing to The Truth About Cars, running his own blog, PlaysWithCars, and joining Jalopnik in April. Two books came out that July: Plays With Cars, a collection of personal car stories, and an e-book, From My Perspective, on subjects away from cars. At Jalopnik he answered readers' letters, shot videos for his YouTube channel and bought interesting used cars they suggested, then wrote about them. One was a 2004 Ferrari 360 Modena, bought on a loan in January 2014 and kept for a year. In January 2016 he bought a 2007 Aston Martin V8 Vantage with a bumper-to-bumper warranty and documented owning it, a story that became the book Bumper to Bumper.

In summer 2016 DeMuro became editor of Autotrader.com's new Oversteer blog and shifted towards filming and writing YouTube reviews. His channel covers cars mostly from the 1970s to the present, from the Ford GT, Bugatti Chiron and Ferrari F40 to the Tesla Model 3 and BMW Isetta.

Doug DeMuro, Donut Media, Roadkill and Cleetus McFarland from 2009 to 201620092016Cleetus McFarlandFrom 2009Drag racing and stunts, over 4.8 million subscribersRoadkill2012-2018Junkyard project cars; not renewed after November 2024Donut MediaFrom 2015Explainers, builds, podcastsDoug DeMuroFrom 2016Reviews scored out of 100, over 5 million subscribers
The four car YouTube channels by start year, from Cleetus McFarland in 2009 to Doug DeMuro in 2016.
Four car channels, four routes: an auction site, a toy line, a magazine and a race track.

How a Doug DeMuro review works

The format is consistent. DeMuro covers the exterior and interior "quirks and features," drives the car, then finishes with a score between 10 and 100 that he calls the DougScore. The number is built from ten separate categories about usability and fun. Most of the cars he reviews are not press cars: they belong to dealerships and private owners. For a short time he also worked with a car-sharing company, renting cars on his travels within a budget it set and reviewing them.

The DougScore debuted on a 2006 Range Rover of the third generation, which DeMuro picked up in December 2012 from a CarMax in Marietta, Georgia. It had its own run of videos and articles listing every repair. DeMuro paid $3,899 for a six-year, 66,000-mile bumper-to-bumper warranty, and by the time it expired the car had received over $21,000 of repair work. A second channel, More Doug DeMuro, launched in August 2018 and carried opinion, vlogs and question-and-answer videos; it had nearly 750,000 subscribers by March 2023, and DeMuro merged it with the Cars & Bids channel that year. In June 2017 he appeared on Jay Leno's Garage and tried to identify cars while blindfolded, and in March 2019 he reviewed Leno's McLaren F1.

Cars & Bids

DeMuro conceived the auction site in 2019 and launched it in 2020 after leaving Autotrader.com. It was aimed at enthusiast cars and at first listed only vehicles built in 1981 or later. The first car on offer was his own E 63 AMG Wagon, a 2012 Mercedes-Benz. He has since sold more of his cars there, including a 2018 Kia Stinger GT2, a 2020 Land Rover Defender (the first car he bought new), a 1994 Audi RS2 Avant that reached him from Japan by way of Canada, and a 1998 Mercedes-Benz A140 brought in during 2023.

During 2021 the site reported 4,000 listings and US$75 million paid out by buyers. The Chernin Group took its majority stake in January 2023 for US$37 million. From 2 May 2025 the site began accepting vehicles built before 1981.

Donut Media

Donut Media, also called Donut, is an American automotive YouTube channel, with Real Mechanic Stuff as a second channel. Matt Levin, who had headed product at AwesomenessTV, started it in 2015 alongside Ben Conrad and Nick Moceri. It opened with a video on the 24 Hours of Lemons, and its first big hit was a 2016 video, Two Grannies, One Lamborghini, which stayed its most-watched upload for years. In February 2018 the team staged its own version of the Tesla Roadster space launch, using a Hot Wheels model. Techstars Ventures led an $800,000 seed round in May 2018, and in November Donut partnered with NASCAR for light-hearted racing content.

The breakthrough came from Up to Speed. In the series, host James Pumphrey explains where cult-favourite cars come from, such as the Suzuki Samurai, Plymouth Barracuda and Nissan GT-R. Levin has said it marked the point where Donut stopped depending on viral one-offs and had a sustainable content model. A "debut" video in February 2016 had listed nine facts about the Nissan 240SX; the real series started in 2017 with a video on the Nissan Skyline.

Donut Media's shows, toys and games

Donut grew beyond video. In June 2021 it put a Kickstarter project online for Stocky, a line of collectable toy cars with cartoonish proportions, the first being an Acura Integra Type R. On 9 November 2021 Recurrent Ventures, owner of The Drive and Car Bibles, bought the company. Donut also became a fixture in racing games: a story called Donut in Forza Horizon 5 in November 2022, another based on its Hi-Low show in June 2023, and a playlist at the launch of The Crew Motorfest in September 2023.

The shows show the range. In HiLow, Pumphrey and Nolan Sykes bought near-identical cars and modified one with expensive parts and one with cheap ones: Nissan 350Zs, Toyota Tacomas, Subaru WRXs for time attack, then Ford Mustang GTs for drag racing in a season that ran from August to 20 December 2024. In Money Pit, Zach Jobe modified a Mazda Miata and later a BMW 3 Series; a 1996 Ford Ranger trophy truck project began in February 2024. A 1995 Honda Civic bought for US$500 in December 2022 received over $50,000 of parts in a bid to beat the latest Civic Type R. Science Garage, Miracle Whips, Tool Party, Past Gas and Wheelhouse filled out the schedule.

Two of the older shows left their mark. Science Garage, hosted by Bart Bidlingmeyer from February 2017 to January 2019, explained a single part or mechanism per episode, and helped build Donut's early following; Bidlingmeyer left in April 2019 to work for Kelley Blue Book and Motor Trend. Miracle Whips, with Byron Bowers from June to October 2018, searched for a car he would happily drive daily for life, and ended when he picked a Nissan GT-R R35.

Change came in 2024. On 21 June, hosts Jeremiah Burton and Zach Jobe, both with the channel for years, said they would depart and launch BigTime. On 2 August Pumphrey said he too would go, setting up a solo channel, Speeed, with friend Jesse Wood. On 27 July 2026 the Donut Podcasts Instagram Story carried a terse farewell, and host Joe Weber confirmed that the podcast division had shut down and staff had been laid off.

Roadkill

The MotorTrend Group produced Roadkill, an online car show fronted by David Freiburger, once an editor at Hot Rod, and Mike Finnegan, formerly on its technical staff. It was filmed mainly in Southern California, with episodes elsewhere in the United States, Canada and Australia. The show ran on YouTube from 2012 until March 2018, then moved exclusively to MotorTrend On Demand, and is now on Discovery+. Dodge sponsored it in 2015.

Its sayings became part of its identity. Freiburger's philosophy is to skip perfection and just get the thing running. "Because Roadkill" is a comic excuse for any unnecessary or financially reckless job on a car. Freiburger calls any vehicle with working doors, a windshield and headlights "mint". Finnegan's line before cutting up a car is that knowing the rules entitles him to break them, and "Finnenomics" is the joke economics of losing money on a restoration. Cable ties are the budget fix of choice, and "Tony broke it" refers to Tony Angelo's habit of breaking high-performance cars.

Around the two hosts sat a recurring cast. Steve Dulcich is a mechanic whose farm is the backdrop for Roadkill Garage, and his shop dog, Terry the Terrier, is part of the furniture. Lucky Costa, who co-hosts Hot Rod Garage, gets called in when a car needs extra help. Steve Brule co-hosts Engine Masters, Rick Pewe is a former editor of Petersen's 4-Wheel & Offroading Magazine, and Elana Scherr is a former editor-in-chief of Roadkill magazine and its website.

The show spawned three spin-offs, Roadkill Garage with Steve Dulcich, Roadkill's Junkyard Gold with historian Steve Magnante, and Faster with Newbern and Cotten, plus a short-format companion, Roadkill Extra. A quarterly Roadkill Magazine launched in 2015; Finnegan announced on 12 January 2018 that it had ceased publication. In November 2024, when MotorTrend Productions closed, Roadkill and its spin-offs were left without further seasons.

Cleetus McFarland

Garrett Mitchell, who goes by Cleetus McFarland, was born on 5 April 1995 and makes his living as a YouTuber and stock car racer; his channel had passed 4.8 million subscribers by August 2026. He started it on 28 January 2009 while handling social media for the car media firm 1320Video, and later left to run it full time. The Cleetus McFarland name dates from 2015 and comes from a joke character that Kyle Loftis invented, which spread widely after the yearly Rocky Mountain Race Week. His best-known cars are Leroy, a Chevrolet Corvette C5 stripped of its body and fitted with an exo-cage, which won trophies and set records, and Mullet, a purpose-built race car made from a Chevrolet El Camino. In January 2020 he bought the abandoned Desoto Speedway, a 3/8-mile asphalt oval with a figure-8 layout in Florida's Manatee County, and renamed it Freedom Factory.

On the drag strip, Mullet won the McLeod Racing Warriors VS Tres Cuarto category at the Haltech World Cup Finals on 6 November 2022, running 6.474 seconds at 222.95 mph in the final round. In 2023 Leroy won the Grannas Racing Stick Shift class at the same event at 7.325 seconds and 203.95 mph.

His circuit racing career is more recent. At his Stadium Super Trucks debut in Long Beach in 2022 he led the final lap of the second race until a spin at the last jump gave Robby Gordon the win. Later that year he finished third in Race 2 of the Bristol 1000. In 2025 he started his ARCA Menards Series career at Daytona under his real name, finishing 30th after a crash. In 2026 he came back as Cleetus McFarland: 11th at Daytona, fourth in the East Series race at Rockingham and second at Talladega. He tested at Rockingham in February 2026 for a NASCAR Craftsman Truck Series debut in the number 4 for Niece Motorsports, started 12th at Daytona, hit the wall on lap 6 and finished 37th. His three O'Reilly Auto Parts Series starts in the number 33 for Richard Childress Racing began at Rockingham in April and brought a 32nd place there; NASCAR did not approve him for the spring Talladega race because of his lack of experience, and he finished 35th at Nashville.

How the four compare

NameStartedFormatWhere it stands
Doug DeMuroReviews from 2016; Cars & Bids launched 2020Reviews scored out of 100More than 5 million subscribers in April 2026
Donut Media2015Explainers, builds, podcastsPodcast division closed on 27 July 2026
Roadkill2012Junkyard project carsNot renewed after November 2024
Cleetus McFarlandChannel started 2009Drag racing and stuntsPart-time NASCAR, ARCA and dirt racing in 2026

Frequently asked questions

What is the DougScore?
It is Doug DeMuro's rating for the cars he reviews, from 10 to 100. The number is built from scores in ten separate categories related to usability and fun. The first car scored was a 2006 Range Rover.
Who founded Donut Media?
Matt Levin, a former product head at AwesomenessTV, founded Donut Media in 2015 with Ben Conrad and Nick Moceri. Its Up to Speed series, hosted by James Pumphrey, drove its breakout between 2018 and 2020.
What was the Roadkill web series?
It was an automotive show from the MotorTrend Group hosted by David Freiburger and Mike Finnegan. It ran on YouTube from 2012 to March 2018, then moved to MotorTrend On Demand and Discovery+.
Who is Cleetus McFarland?
Garrett Mitchell, born in 1995, is a YouTuber and stock car driver known as Cleetus McFarland. He races part-time in the NASCAR O'Reilly and Craftsman Truck series and in ARCA, and runs Freedom Factory in Florida.
What is Cars & Bids?
It is an online car auction site founded by Doug DeMuro and launched in 2020. The Chernin Group bought a majority stake for US$37 million in January 2023, and the site began listing pre-1981 cars on 2 May 2025.

Sources

  1. Cleetus McFarland - Wikipedia
  2. Doug DeMuro - Wikipedia
  3. Donut Media - Wikipedia
  4. Roadkill (web series) - Wikipedia
Next story / Motorsport

Niece Motorsports: From a 2016 Truck Debut to Chastain's Wins and a Four-Truck Line-Up