Courts, scientists and a motoring association have all weighed in on cars that supposedly run on water, and the physics is not on the inventors' side.
A water-fuelled car supposedly gets its energy directly from water, which contradicts the laws of physics, since water cannot yield chemical energy on its own. The claims have been judged pseudoscience, and several inventors have been convicted of fraud or sued over them.
In 1996 an Ohio court found the inventor of a so-called water fuel cell guilty of "gross and egregious fraud". Stanley Meyer had claimed for years that a dune buggy of his ran on water, and his case is only the most famous of a long run of inventors who have said much the same.
A water-fuelled car, by definition, would get its energy directly from water. The idea has fed patents, newspaper stories, television reports and websites, and the claims have been found to be pseudoscience, with some tied to investment frauds. The money, the physics and the people involved explain why the dream persists, and why none of these cars has been shown to work.
What is a water-fuelled car, and what is it not?
A water-fuelled car is a vehicle that hypothetically takes its energy from water. Some claims say fuel is made on board with no other energy input; others describe a hybrid that draws some power from water as well as from a conventional source such as petrol. Several real technologies sound similar and are not the same thing.
- Water injection adds water to the incoming fuel-air mixture to cool the combustion chambers, which allows higher compression and reduces knock.
- A hydrogen car uses electricity to make hydrogen from water by electrolysis. The hydrogen is a carrier of energy, burned in an engine or turned into electricity in a fuel cell.
- Hydrogen fuel enhancement burns a mixture of hydrogen and conventional fuel, usually to improve economy or cut emissions.
- A steam car uses water as a working fluid, not as a fuel.
- An electric car charged with hydroelectricity gets its energy from the falling water behind a dam, not from the water in the tank.
In 1996 an Ohio court found the inventor of a so-called water fuel cell guilty of gross and egregious fraud.
Can you really run a car on water?
The laws of physics say no. Water is a stable substance, held together by strong chemical bonds. It is the ash of burning hydrogen, if you like: the ball that has already rolled to the bottom of the hill. Its enthalpy of formation is negative, at -285.8 kJ/mol (-68.3 kcal/mol), which means energy has to be put in to break water apart, and no other compound of hydrogen and oxygen has a more negative figure, so there is no other route that releases energy.
Most water-fuelled proposals use electrolysis to separate water into hydrogen and oxygen, then recombine them. The first law of thermodynamics says the energy needed to separate the elements equals the energy released when they recombine, assuming no losses, so there is nothing left over. The second law is harsher still: the useful energy released is necessarily less than the energy supplied.
The inventors who said they had done it
The record of claims stretches across nine decades and several continents. The first on file is Charles H. Garrett, who allegedly showed a water-fuelled car "for several minutes", reported by The Dallas Morning News on 8 September 1935. His patent, issued the same year, shows a carburetor like an ordinary float type but with electrolysis plates in the lower portion. It does not identify a new source of energy.
In 1973, Malcolm Vincent of Nelson, New Zealand, starred in a four-minute newsreel about his engine. He said he had driven hundreds of miles at up to 60 miles an hour with a prototype in a car, and told the reporter that it worked on a hydraulic principle, with an ordinary electric starter providing an initial thrust.
Stanley Meyer and the water fuel cell
Meyer claimed at least as far back as 1980 to have a dune buggy that ran on water, though he gave inconsistent explanations. Sometimes he said a "water splitter" had replaced the spark plugs; at other times he described a "fuel cell" subjected to electrical resonance that split a water mist into hydrogen and oxygen, which were burned back into water vapour in an ordinary engine to produce net energy. His claims were never independently verified. An Ohio court in 1996 found him guilty of "gross and egregious fraud". Meyer died in 1998 of an aneurysm, although conspiracy theories insist he was poisoned.
The 2000s: companies, investors and prosecutions
In 2002 Hydrogen Technology Applications patented an electrolyser and trademarked the name "Aquygen" for the hydrogen-oxygen gas mixture it produced. The device had begun as an alternative to oxyacetylene welding, but the company claimed it could run a vehicle exclusively on water, leaning on an unproven state of matter it called "magnegases" and a discredited theory of magnecules. Founder Dennis Klein said talks were under way with a big American carmaker and that Washington wanted Hummers built with his technology. The company no longer claims a car can run on water alone and markets Aquygen as a way of raising fuel efficiency, which makes it hydrogen fuel enhancement.
Also in 2002, Genesis World Energy announced a market-ready device that would separate hydrogen and oxygen and recombine them, and in 2003 said it had been adapted to power cars. The company collected over $2.5 million from investors, yet no device reached the market. In 2006 its owner, Patrick Kelly, was sentenced in New Jersey to five years in prison and ordered to pay $400,000 in restitution.
In June 2008 the Japanese company Genepax unveiled a car it said ran on only water and air. It declined to reveal the "core part" of the invention, but disclosed an onboard "membrane electrode assembly" extracting hydrogen by a mechanism similar to the reaction of metal hydride and water. Speculation followed that the metal hydride was consumed and was the true source of energy, making it a hydride-fuelled "hydrogen on demand" car, not a water-fuelled one. Popular Mechanics called the claims "rubbish". The demonstration vehicle was a REVAi electric car, made in India and sold in the UK as the G-Wiz, and in early 2009 Genepax closed its website, citing large development costs.
Also in 2008, Sri Lankan media reported that Thushara Priyamal Edirisinghe claimed to drive about 300 km (190 miles) on 3 litres of water. He showed the technology to Prime Minister Ratnasiri Wickramanayaka, who offered the government's full support, but was arrested within months, suspected of investment fraud. The same year, Formosa Plastics successfully sued the Filipino inventor Daniel Dingel for fraud. Dingel, who had claimed since 1969 to have made water usable as fuel and had gone into partnership with Formosa in 2000, was sentenced at the age of 82 to 20 years' imprisonment.
The 2010s and after
In December 2011 Ghulam Sarwar claimed a car using 60% water and 40% diesel or fuel, which he hoped to make run on water alone by the end of June 2012, and which would emit "only oxygen". In July 2012 the Pakistani Agha Waqar Ahmad described a "water kit" of a jar, bubbler and pipe feeding "HHO" to the engine, working only with distilled water, and applied for a patent. Some Pakistani scientists called it a fraud that violated thermodynamics.
The most recent case is the Indonesian inventor Aryanto Misel, who said in May 2022 that his Nikuba device turns water into hydrogen for motorcycles, needing only 1 litre of water for 500 kilometres. In July 2023 he claimed that Lamborghini, Ducati and Ferrari were interested and said he would sell the device for 15 billion rupiahs. Scientists from Indonesia's National Research and Innovation Agency called the device theoretically impossible, and said the Italian manufacturers had expressed no interest.
Water-fuelled claims at a glance
| Claimant | Year | Claim | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Charles H. Garrett | 1935 | Electrolytic carburetor ran a car for several minutes | Patent identifies no new energy source |
| Stanley Meyer | From 1980 | Dune buggy with a water fuel cell | Found guilty of fraud, Ohio, 1996 |
| Genesis World Energy | 2002-2003 | Device to power cars from water | Over $2.5 million raised; owner jailed in 2006 |
| Genepax | 2008 | Car running on water and air | Called "rubbish" by Popular Mechanics; website closed 2009 |
| Daniel Dingel | Since 1969 | Technology using water as fuel | Sued for fraud 2008; 20-year sentence |
| Aryanto Misel | 2022-2023 | Nikuba, 1 litre of water for 500 km | Called theoretically impossible by scientists |
Do HHO kits and gasoline pills work?
Alongside cars that run on water alone are claims that burning hydrogen or oxyhydrogen with petrol or diesel increases mileage. Those claims are debated. A number of websites promote "HHO", selling plans for do-it-yourself electrolysers or kits with promises of large gains in fuel efficiency. A spokesman for the American Automobile Association conceded that the devices look as though they might work, then added that they do not.
A related genre is the "gasoline pill", an additive said to turn water into usable fuel, rather as a carbide lamp generates combustible gas. Those claims are false and often fraudulent, because water itself cannot add any energy to the process.
What does work: hydrogen on demand and compressed air
A genuine cousin exists. A hydrogen on demand vehicle makes its hydrogen from water through a chemical reaction, then burns it in an engine or feeds it to a fuel cell. The energy comes from the chemical that reacts with water, so physics does not rule it out. Aluminium, magnesium and sodium borohydride all react with water to release hydrogen and have been used in prototypes. The catch is that the chemical eventually runs out, and the energy needed to make such compounds is more than the energy obtained from them.
One design, from scientists at the University of Minnesota and the Weizmann Institute of Science, relies on boron. New Scientist covered it in July 2006 under the headline "A fuel tank full of water". A vehicle would be filled with water and boron instead of petrol and would give off boron trioxide. Pure boron is hard to prepare and not found in nature, so a practical version needs a cheap way of making it.
Air as an energy store
Compressed air is a different honest idea: the vehicle carries tanks of pressurised air, released through a pneumatic motor. Compressed-air traction has long pedigree, from mine locomotives and Paris trams in the 19th century to torpedoes, and pneumatic locomotives were used while building the Gotthard Rail Tunnel from 1872 to 1882. Mekarski system trams ran in regular service in Nantes and Paris for over 30 years. In 1903 the Liquid Air Company of London made several compressed-air and liquefied-air cars. The recurring weaknesses were low torque and the cost of compressing the air.
Recent work is more promising. In 2020 Dr Reza Alizade Evrin of Ontario Tech University published an isothermal compressed-air prototype with a global energy efficiency of 74% and a range of 140 km (87 mi), comparable to the 73-90% quoted for electric vehicles with lithium-ion batteries. Its tanks use low pressure, and exhaust air recovery drives a paraffin heat exchanger. Composite tanks of thermoplastic are about 70% lighter than steel and rupture, rather than explode, in a crash. Against that, compressed air stores little energy for its size, and tank pressure falls as air is drawn off, which trims the power available.
Experiments have been varied. In 2008 engineering students at Deakin University in Australia were joint winners of the Ford T2 competition with a compressed-air and natural gas car with a 200 km (120 mi) range. Toyota's Ku:Rin three-wheeler of 2011 reached 129.2 km/h (80.3 mph) on compressed air alone, and Honda showed an Air concept in Los Angeles in 2010. Peugeot Citroen's Hybrid Air used compressed air to move the wheels below 43 mph (69 km/h) and was claimed to reach up to 141 miles per gallon, but its head left Peugeot in 2014 and the project ended in 2015 when no partner could be found to share the development costs.
What this means for someone buying or driving a car
The practical lesson is a caution. A device that promises to run an engine on water, or to multiply fuel economy with an HHO kit, asks the buyer to accept something that physics does not allow, and several of the people behind such claims have ended up in court or under arrest. The American Automobile Association's blunt verdict on HHO devices is worth remembering: they look as if they could work, but they do not. A hydrogen car is a different proposition entirely, because the hydrogen is made with outside electricity and treated honestly as stored energy.
Is any water-powered or air-powered car close to production?
New water claims keep appearing, the latest being the 2022 and 2023 Nikuba statements, and so far the pattern is the same: unverified assertions, followed by scientists rejecting them. The more credible research runs elsewhere. The 2020 compressed-air prototype's efficiency and range could be raised, its developer says, through structural tanks, high-pressure tanks, new rotary engines and a better heat exchanger. Commercial compressed-air cars remain unrealised: by August 2017 none had gone into production, Tata had indicated it would begin selling vehicles from 2020, and MDI's US distributor said production of the AIRPod would begin in Europe in 2018. As of 2024, neither developer has begun production.




